Artist: PJ Harvey
Title: Rid of Me
Where bought: The Wiz
Why don't I have PJ Harvey's "Dry" on this log? Because for a while, I only had it on cassette, and I got it on digital some years later, but I never had it on CD. Still love it, though not as much as I love "Rid of Me". One of the most unapologetic albums ever recorded, it sits as raw confrontation and a declaration of defiance of any expectation of what anyone thinks she should be.
She starts the album with the title track, answering her debut-album detractors by stating not only has she stayed around, but "don't you wish you never met her?" The singles "50 Foot Queenie" and "Man-Size" are testaments to the strength of her immense talent and voice. However, they pale when compared to "Rub 'Til It Bleeds", a slow boil that explodes in screaming ecstasy; a fierce statement on double standards and cultural norms. Enthusiastically recommended.
Artist: PJ Harvey
Title: To Bring You My Love
Where bought: The Wiz
PJ Harvey's first single from "To Bring You My Love" was "Down By the Water", which is just as creepy as the title would suggest. She seemed to be more of a storyteller on this one, and she started using even more instruments, including electronics, possibly to compensate for the loss of drummer Ellis. This is sort of a stylistic shift, with some quietly difficult songs like "Working for the Man", and with one that is almost like an arena rocker ("Long Snake Moan").
It's definitely her most varied record, and some have called it her best up to that point. I'm still a big fan of "Rid of Me", but if you're eyes weren't widened enough after the first two records, this one will do that and make your jaw drop.
Artist: PJ Harvey
Title: Is This Desire?
Where bought: The Wiz
"Is This Desire?" is PJ Harvey at her Patti Smith-iest, creating her most difficult work yet. After "To Bring You My Love", her most textured work to that point, I was wondering if she had enough inspiration to follow it up well. After hearing "A Perfect Day Elise", my concerns were allayed, though it was a disturbing song. I think the fact this didn't get a lot of attention was due more to the fact that the music was less stark and her voice less forceful, but she would return to form with her most accessible and last accessible album next.
Artist: PJ Harvey
Title: Stories From the City, Stories From the Sea
Where bought: Amazon
I see "Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea" as PJ Harvey's last really accessible album. After a bit of experimentation on "Is This Desire?", this album goes back to songs that are more immediate. But they do stay interesting after repeated listens.
I remember leaving work late one night and listening to it as I rode the train, which was then delayed and re-routed, and I didn't get home until after midnight, but I had "This Mess We're In", with Ms. Harvey and Thom Yorke to keep me company. That helped burn this album into my memory forever. Can't ask for much more than that. Well, I did ask to get home earlier, but no one was going to help me with that one.
As far as the rest of her albums, I either bought them on CD, ripped them and re-sold them, or I just bought the digital versions. I didn't hate them, in fact I really respect them, but I just didn't love them.
No comments:
Post a Comment