Thursday, November 5, 2020

The Great Re-Rip of 2020, Day 71, October 25, 2020

Artist:  New Order

Title:  Movement

Where bought:  My sister gave it to me

The more recent literature I've read on this album has been kind to it in hindsight.  "Movement" was the first full album that the former Joy Division members released as New Order.  Understandably, it sounds a lot like Joy Division.  It was released just 18 months after the former band's lead singer committed suicide, so any release put out that quickly would have to be some what similar to the former band.  It also seems to make sense that the album is a little depressing, as that was the former band's forte.  Maybe that makes it too "easy", since it was already in their wheelhouse, but a band at a crossroads, if they can persevere, will not sound like what they eventually become, which is true in this case.  In hindsight.


Artist:  New Order

Title:  Power, Corruption and Lies

Where bought:  My sister gave it to me

After a bunch of singles and their debut album with the new moniker, New Order tried to distance themselves further from Joy Division with their second album, "Power, Corruption and Lies", which started with the sunniest-sounding song they had recorded up to that point, "Age of Consent".  Now, the lyrics are not the happiest conversation you've ever heard, but it describes someone who is standing up for himself/herself and not letting someone else own their emotions.  

Is this where Joy Division would have gone?  Maybe, maybe not, but the dub-infused tracks on the album give a more likely indication, and when you listen to "Closer" and "Power..." back to back, ignoring the singles and "Movement", it makes for some interesting "what if?" conversations.

Artist:  New Order

Title:  Low-Life

Where bought:  My sister gave it to me

I didn't get into New Order until after "Substance" came out, and even after that, it took me a little while to catch up to the previous albums.  "Low-Life" was the one that took me the longest to get, which was not quite explainable because I loved "Love Vigilantes" and "The Perfect Kiss" from hearing them on WDRE.  

I also loved "Sub-Culture", but I was unaware that the version on the album was completely different from the re-mixed version on "Substance".  I do tend to favor the versions I hear first, and I think it's justified in this case, even with the poppy backing vocals in the latter version, because the vocals on the original version are too tentative.

Artist:  New Order

Title:  Brotherhood

Where bought:  My sister gave it to me

My sister was really happy when I got a CD player for my high school graduation, because that made it easier to buy Christmas and birthday gifts for me.  But it also made it a little more annoying for her, because I would start taking her CDs, sometimes without asking.  Her copies of New Order's "Power..." and "Brotherhood" were victims here, and it was a little bit her fault because she was the one that turned me on to "Substance".  It was also really cool to have her versions, because they were both imports.  Most of the time, I would give the CDs back to her after taping them, but these stayed in my collection, because, well, she never asked for them back.  That, and I think she took them from a friend of hers.


No comments:

Post a Comment