Sunday, May 31, 2015

"I Love Rock 'n' Roll" - Joan Jett and the Blackhearts

First off, let me say that I know very little about the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.  I don't even know if I spelled it correctly.  That said, I'm sure I'm preaching to all kinds of choirs here, but I really don't understand the selection process; I just find it really annoying. 

It seems like it's all done by lobbying.  How else do you explain backing bands making it into the Hall?  And how about other bands that have dubious "rock" credentials?  I have nothing against Joan Jett.  That's important for me to say, because I have nothing against Bill Mazeroski either, and I love (as a Mets fan) the fact that he hit a home run to beat the Yankees in a World Series, but there's no way in the world he should be in the Baseball Hall of Fame.  With that in mind, does a band that is best-known for playing cover songs more deserving than easily more influential bands like Big Star, Joy Division, Television, Joe Jackson and Ministry? 

Longevity doesn't seem to be an issue, because the Sex Pistols are in, and they only had one album.  Big Star and Joy Division had two each.  Television had two in their heyday, and they most surely influenced Talking Heads and Blondie, who are both in.  Elvis Costello and Joe Jackson have been similarly adventurous in their careers, and they have been equally successful in the pop world, so why choose one and not the other?  Further, didn't Ministry basically invent a sub-genre of heavy metal as brutal and obnoxious (though sometimes dishonest and pretentious) as the Sex Pistols and the Ramones did?  Who wants to bet that Nine Inch Nails makes it in before Ministry?
 
At the end of the day, it's not a hall of any real reverence.  It's a big Hard Rock Cafe lobby.

Sunday, May 24, 2015

"A Praise Chorus" - Jimmy Eat World

I remember reading an article about the 2004 Alexander Payne film "Sideways" shortly after it was released.  It wasn't really a review; it was more an observation about the many critiques that were favorable, and the opinion as to why that was so.  The columnist theorized that the movie was well-liked by so many critics because the film was about the thankless lengths that one goes to in critiquing something.  That was something that critics could relate to, and apparently it really spoke to them, and maybe they even felt it validated them.  I read that article, and it reminded me of this song.

I consider myself a very novice music critic, but even as a fan, I do feel a similar validation when I  hear songs mentioned that I know.  Jimmy Eat World belts out lyrics from "Our House", "Don't Let's Start" and other songs, and it makes me smile.  It lights me up.  Its upbeat tempo helps, and it takes me along for the ride.  (Later on Bleed American, they play "Authority Song", a reference to the John Cougar Mellencamp track, and they mention the Jesus and Mary Chain's Automatic, but they call the band the "JAMC", which puts me in full geek mode when I hear it.  "I know what they're talking about!")

Now, do I feel validated because I heard just anyone talk about songs I know and like?  I think it's more that it's a band that knows what they're doing that referenced those songs.  Those who can't, teach, right?  Critics are, then, failed artists, or just wish they were artists.  It's an overgeneralization, of course, but I don't deny that I wish I could create art that would be respected.  I just haven't.

At the same time, the unique lexicon of songs that I like is important to me.  I just never think it's important to anyone else, even in parts.  Someone just told me that it was important to them.  Someone I respect.  It's little things like that I need to keep me going.  Even if it's not important to you today.