Sunday, August 1, 2021

"Live Learn and Forget" - Nada Surf

When the pandemic of 2020 hit, many people made resolutions.  Some wanted to become home chefs.  Some took up an instrument.  Some tried learning a new language.  I did none of that.  I listened to even more music.

However, I made a mistake.  It's kind of a big one, but it's somewhat fixable.  I've gotten used to (I hesitate to use the word "addicted" because now I only go shopping every few months) buying a lot of used CDs at record stores, especially for $1 or $2, where I would just buy a stack of them, even if I didn't love the artist.  I would get them because it had one or two songs I liked but didn't have, and I was rolling the dice that there was another song or two that I would like.  I would also get them if they filled a gap in my collection of that particular artist.  I am also trying to update my "Top 1000" list and want to make sure I leave out as few obvious gaps as possible.  If I found a band or an album that I felt that I should know about, then I had to pick up that CD.  My usual M.O. is to listen to the album three times over three weeks, pick out the songs I like best for my mp3 player, and move the rest to the archive.

So what was the mistake?  I did this with the bargain albums as well as with the newer albums that I really wanted to listen to (favorite bands and such), and I have just been piling them onto the same playlist, listening to them through all the same way.  No listening many times, and they are then more easily forgotten, or really, just under-appreciated.

I didn't always do this, of course.  There was a time where I would listen to an album I bought every day for a couple of months, suffering through the songs I didn't love and basking in the  ones I did, but still soaking in all of them.  I'd buy the cassette or CD (and copy the CD to a cassette), and I would listen to it on the bus or in the car to and from school and work.  (It was the late 1980s and early 1990s, so cassettes were still my preferred version of music appreciation on-the-go.)  Some have written about this in the past - I had a relationship with the music.  It could have been the individual album or the set of songs I taped off of the radio - at that time, each occurred at more of my life-defining events (most of them probably had to do with crushes, but come on, who was completely emotionally stable in high school?).  They bring back those memories, both good and bad.

In these times, I bought an album because I really wanted it, so I made the effort to listen to it over and over to get into what they were saying, to see if it made sense for me to relate to or believe.  I don't do that much anymore.  Sometimes it does happen, for example, with Phoebe Bridgers and Katie Pruitt (I still feel compelled to listen to those albums all the way through or just not at all), but the old Butter 08 and Matthew Sweet albums I bought were just to see if there were a few songs from them about which I can be conversant should the need arise.  And maybe, just maybe, there will be a song that I could add to my "anytime" playlist - a grouping of songs where all covet to be included (snicker).  These songs are not tied to events as much, because the events just go by that much faster.

I do miss the liner notes, lyrics, artwork, and other information from the more tactile media.  That's what helped me memorize the names of the band members, the exact lyrics (even when I think they sang slightly different words than what was printed), the placement of the songs on each side of the album, and even the names of the producers and the engineers.  Granted, this was more nerdy, but it was still integral in having a real relationship with the music.

To be clear, the disservice is not being done to these latter albums, but only to the ones that I obtained new and were released recently, like Bob Mould and Jesu, and to the classics I've been "researching", like the first four X albums.

Now, to understand what led up to this change in my listening habits, let's analyze what has happened between then and now (other than the pandemic):

  • I got a job, got married, had a kid, bought a house and, eventually, a dog.  Time is at a premium.  I can't spend hours and hours every day listening to music, even when I am working from home.
  • Used record prices have gone down.  When I first started buying used CDs in the early 1990s, they were about half the price of a new CD.  There were no $1-$2 bins other than cutouts, which almost always had garbage.  Now, many used record stores have these cheap bins because they can buy the CDs for a quarter and turn them around for the aforementioned price.  Some CDs command higher prices, but for these others, where if you were familiar with it at all, you remember only one song, it's worth buying it for a dollar and re-selling it for a quarter even if you ultimately liked only the one song because it's still cheaper than buying the one mp3 online.
  • Where I grew in Brooklyn, no one had garage sales.  In New Jersey, where I live now, everyone does, and they're all looking to get rid of their music.  For example, the Police album on the below list, I got from a garage sale.  Technically, my daughter got it, but without the jewel case, and she told the homeowner that she was going to use it to paint and decorate the walls in her room, so he just gave it to her.  I saw it in the pile of junk she was going to use to build her "found art" creation out of and ripped it before she got a chance to paint over it.
  • Streaming content.  There is so much more I can (and do) spend my time watching and listening to.  This includes TV shows, and, more importantly, podcasts.  I listen to a lot of news podcasts as well as music podcasts, like All Songs Considered, and the Revelation and Dischord discography podcasts.  All worthy listens, but they take away a chunk of time every week that could be used listening to music.
  • This leads to another problem - multi-tasking.  If I listen to music while I'm working or reading or cooking, I have less attention on the music than I did if I was riding the bus or train back and forth to school or in my bedroom just letting loose.  As I wrote this paragraph, I was listening to Oh Pep! and suddenly realized I wasn't really listening to it.  Nothing really soaks in that way.
  • What further compounds that issue is the way I listen to it.  Listening to music on external speakers and listening to them on headphones and listening to them in the car are three different experiences.  Headphones are the most immersive, clearly, followed by the car, and lastly with external speakers.  Why?  Because when I listen on my bluetooth speakers, chances are I'm doing something else.  See multi-tasking bullet above.
Maybe life just moves too fast in my later years, and I don't have the time to let the music define any significant moments in my life.  Those things have forced me to compartmentalize my time to when I could listen.  At the end of the day, this makes sense, as I'm listening to music faster and in keeping with how many events are happening, but the moments don't burn into my soul because I don't have enough time to think about them, and neither does the music.  Sometimes it does, but it's rare.

The bottom line is that there is a lot of music out there that I want to listen to, and the more I actually do listen to, the more influences I hear and want to hear more of.  I am no longer the emotionally fragile teen or college student who needs this music to help define his life or validate his feelings.  I still need it to help navigate life, but I very much have my own opinions about values of a proper life in this world.  I can take their views with a grain of salt, like I do with everyone else, but as evidenced by the fact that I got rid of the blind spot of never learning how to ride a bicycle, the training wheels are off, as it were, and I can do my own life.  And I think that was always the point of this whole art form.  Most musicians want you to live your own life, not just do what they say.  Is it fixable though?  Yes, I just have to make sure I listen to the new stuff more.  I guess.  God, I love music.

Epilogue - This is all the music I'd bought in the period of March 2020-March 2021, the first year of lockdown/pandemic.  A lot of it was bought "used" from beloved record stores (in-person or on Discogs) like Generation Records (NYC), Repo Records (Philadelphia), Vintage Vinyl (Fords, NJ - R.I.P.), and Princeton Record Exchange (Princeton, NJ), as well as digitally on Bandcamp (especially on specific Fridays, where all the proceeds go to the artists) or directly from the band or the label.  Now, I wanted to support these stores and bands, but I'm not rich.  I also sold a bunch of stuff at the same time and got back some of the money I spent.

Alphaville - The Singles Collection
Bel Canto - Birds of Passage
Bettie Serveert - Palomine
Bis - This Is Teen-C Power!
Blake Babies - Earwig
Bob Mould - Blue Hearts (new)
Bold - The Search: 1985-1989
Book of Love - Lullaby
Brendan Perry - Songs of Disenchantment - Music from the Greek Underground (new)
Burn - Last Great Sea
Chain of Strength - The One Thing That Still Holds True
Circle Jerks - Group Sex
Coriky - Coriky (new)
Cro-Mags - The Age of Quarrel
Death Cab for Cutie - The Blue EP (new)
Death Cab for Cutie - The Georgia EP (new)
Del Amitri - Twisted
Dog Faced Hermans - Hum of Life
Drive Like Jehu - Drive Like Jehu
Ednaswap - Wonderland Park
Erasure - Erasure
Failure - In the Future Your Body Will Be the Furthest Thing from Your Mind (new-ish)
Fiona Apple - Fetch the Boltcutters (new)
Greater Than One - Index
Ida - The Braille Night
Inspiral Carpets - Cool As…EP
Jello Biafra & the Melvins - Sieg Howdy!
Jesu - Never (new)
Jesu - Terminus (new)
Kate Bush - The Sensual World
Katie Pruitt - Expectations (new)
Liz Phair - Exile in Guyville
Lo-Fidelity Allstars - How to Operate with a Blown Mind
Loverboy - Big Ones
Lydia Loveless - Daughter (new)
Matthew Sweet - 100% Fun
Meat Beat Manifesto - RUOK?
Mission of Burma - Mission of Burma
Nada Surf - Never Not Together (new)
Nation of Ulysses - 13 Point Program to Destroy America
Negative Approach - Total Recall
Peter Gabriel - Us
Rites of Spring - End on End
School of Fish - School of Fish
Sense Field - Building
Sick of It All - Built to Last
Sick of It All - Sick of It All
Sloan - Smeared
Son Volt - Union (new)
The Connells - Stone Cold Yesterday- Best Of The Connells
The Jayhawks - Smile
The Nerves - The Nerves
The Police - Outlandos d'Amour
The Primitives - Lovely
The Replacements - Pleased to Meet Me
The Sisters of Mercy - First and Last Always
The Sisters of Mercy - Some Girls Wander By Mistake
The Young Gods - The Young Gods
This Picture - An Violent Impression
Throwing Muses - Sun Racket (new)
Toad the Wet Sprocket - Pale
Translator - Heartbeats and Triggers
Various Artists - Animal Liberation
Various Artists - Matador at 15
Various Artists - Rubáiyát Elektra's 40th Anniversary
Various Artists - We Bite America - The Collection
Vitamin Z - Rites of Passage
X - Los Angeles
X - More Fun in the New World
X - Under the Big Black Sun
X - Wild Gift