Sunday, April 24, 2016

"Hit Song" - Peter Murphy

I know the first four Peter Murphy solo albums pretty well.  If I were to rank them from most favorite to least favorite:  1. Deep (1989), 2. Love Hysteria (1988), 3. Should the World Fail to Fall Apart (1986), 4. Holy Smoke (1992).  Now, this is not an unusual arc, but every career is different, and it always bothered me hat I couldn't put my finger on why I liked certain albums more than others.

Then it came to me.  The first and last one weren't spooky enough.  Love Hysteria and Deep definitely had their lighter moments, the most obvious being the classic single, "Indigo Eyes".  However, they also had some capably-crafted haunting moments, like "All Night Long" and the almost Top-40 hit "Cuts You Up".  

Now, these songs were not cloning or even recalling Bauhaus.  His former band's piercing, jagged riffs were few and far between in his solo works.  These were moody tracks that were heartfelt at the same time, letting you in just enough, but still keeping you far enough away so that you knew you weren't exactly inside.  (The video for "All Night Long" had Murphy partly in shadows and hiding behind sheets, making it difficult for the viewer to focus on him.)  Murphy's voice was warm and flowing.  It always had an air of pretentiousness, but I can't imagine anyone thinking he would have toned down his crooning that much after moving from the quintessential Gothic band to a solo career. 

The biggest issue with the four albums is that they're all choppy and inconsistent.  The songs are just stronger on the middle two.  The first album was a little too mechanical-sounding at times, but this was forgivable for a first solo album, where he was trying to differentiate himself not only from Bauhaus, but also from Murphy's side project with Japan's Mick Karn called Dali's Car.  

Holy Smoke was a different story.  I loved Deep, and I was really looking forward to this follow-up.  It just never really gelled.  It's not fair to ask for a "Cuts You Up 2", but there needs to be an air of sincerity.  I just didn't get a sense of that from this album.  Songs like "The Sweetest Drop" and "Keep Me from Harm" are strong enough, but like Phil Collins' "But Seriously", he pretty much lost his eerie side.  And a song like "Hit Song", though it may have been cheeky, was still annoyingly obvious, with its slow drum machine march and incongruous, intermittent vibratto.

Look, I get that each artist has to follow his/her own path, and far be it from me to tell anyone how to run their career, especially a career in music.  To his credit, Murphy had several solo albums after that one, and he never really re-adopted the "Gothic-lite" delivery technique, getting even a little more poppy.  But I'm human.  I wanted "Cuts You Up 2".  Doesn't make me a bad person.


Sunday, April 10, 2016

"Sea" - Codeine

This is going to seem like a weird lead-in.  One of the things that was so impressive about the movie "The Birdcage" (the American version of the French play and film, "La Cage Aux Folles"), other than the manic, in-your-face acting, was the one lead that didn't play his usual manic self.  The late, great Robin Williams was incredibly controlled in that performance, letting loose only for a couple of quick outbursts.  Otherwise, his character was the "straight man" (who also happened to be gay).

Control is a very human quality, and not everyone has it.  When I was in college, I had listened to the Codeine releases Barely Real and The White Birch, but other than "Realize" and "Tom", the tortoise-paced records didn't make enough of an impression on me back then.

I had some extra credits on emusic.com recently, and I decided to buy all three of their records (including their first, "Frigid Stars LP").  After listening to them all the way through a couple of times, it almost got to be unbearable.  It's just too slow.  Now, I know their catalog should be treated like candy:  not a whole bag in one sitting.  You sorta can't see the forest for the trees after a while.  The same applies to their short history.  If you have a whole bowl of Skittles, the first one you eat will be more or less the same as the last one, save for the color and flavor, incidental to the general chemical mixture.  Codeine's catalog followed a similar aesthetic:  the pace is slow throughout almost every song.  The lyrics and bars change from song to song, but they all just crawl.  All of them, from beginning to end.  Although they can dramatically change volume mid-track, they do not succumb to a tendency to succumb to bursts of speed (like Slint, who sound very much like Codeine at times, and vice versa, since they both recorded around the same time).

You'd have thought that by the third release, "The White Birch", they may have wanted to try a somewhat different approach, mix it up a little.  I mean, it's only human for a band to want to rock out once in a while, right?  You'd have been wrong.  "Sea" opens the album with their standard low bass, light percussion, slowly-strummed jangly guitar (like Johnny Marr at 1/8th speed), and whispered, almost drowned-out vocals.  Most impressively, guitarist and vocalist Steve Immerwahr, takes the phrase "I understand" and drags it out for about 25 seconds.  He holds the third syllable for about 13 seconds at a low note before pausing for a few more seconds and releasing, at a higher note and a glorious crescendo, "stannnnnnnnnnnd" (yes, kinda like the R.E.M. song, but nowhere near as irritating).  I knew what you were half-expecting, and I didn't quite give it to you, but I wanted you to know I understood the difference.  He does this twice in the song, changing nothing the second time.

It took me a few listens to pick up on that, and hey, I still don't love them, but gosh-darnit do I respect the hell out of it.