If I've named a deep album cut from a relatively obscure 80s band, I swear my aim isn't to be pretentious.
No two persons' record collections will ever be the same. That's nothing profound. But, am I ever to expect someone will know songs that are in my collection, just because they also know the Smiths and New Order?
I first heard of Legal Reins during my high school days in the late 1980s listening to WDRE. They were playing the single "Wait for Fire Burning". I only had a cassette recording of the song off the radio, so years later, I wanted to see if I could find an mp3 or a cheap version of the CD to replace the crappy-sounding (see previous "Merchandise" blog post) cassette version.
I got the CD through a now-defunct trading service called lala.com. Plenty of people still had CDs in their collection that they didn't want anymore but couldn't be bothered with the process of selling them. Or, if they could sell them on ebay.com or half.com, they wouldn't make enough back to make the effort worthwhile. Lala.com offered an alternative. They made a community of people who had CDs they didn't want anymore, and they would make them available to anyone on the site. In addition to putting up CDs you had and didn't want, you could put up a "wish list" of CDs you wanted but didn't have. If you put up one that someone else wanted, they would send you an email once they found a buyer. If you were truly willing to part with it, you would confirm with the site, and they would send you the buyer's address and a postage-paid mailer to safely deliver the CD. If you were the seller, it would cost you nothing, though you wouldn't get anything either. However, if you wanted to buy something, you had to pay $1.75 for each CD, and you had to have had at least one CD from your collection already given up. It worked for me, because paying just $1.75 for a CD that I wanted made up for the few cents that I might have made selling the unwanted ones. Even if I only wanted one or two songs from a CD, I could have a whole album cheaply rather than buying $1 mp3s.
OK, I think I was rambling a little bit there, but I think you get the point. Unfortunately, the service didn't last. Their business model changed in favor of selling music instead of brokering it, and it was shut down not long after being purchased by Apple.
After I got the notice that I was being sent the Legal Reins CD "Please, the Pleasure", I got an internal email from the user who sent me the CD (another feature of the service). He had asked me how I had heard of the band, and I explained it was from my high school days on my local alternative music station.
I didn't know if I should have continued the conversation after that. The guy lived in Michigan, and I was living in Brooklyn, so it wasn't like we were going together to see shows of bands that didn't exist anymore. However, I can never tell if people want to talk more about music they like. A lot of people I know like what they like and don't talk about it. I can talk to my brothers and a few friends about alternative music and some of the more popular stuff we both like, but who can I talk to about Legal Reins, Head Candy, and Uncle Green?
Not that have to talk to anyone about it, though it may be therapeutic in a way to know I'm not alone. Or maybe I like thinking I'm a little unique, or as my wife likes to put it, "weird".