Sunday, November 30, 2014

"It's Not for You" - Velocity Girl

No two music careers will ever be the same.  Some bands or artists will have long successful careers, some won't.  And you can never tell when or if they have peaked.  It's that mystery that is part of the reason I keep buying albums from artists even though I haven't sampled them first.  
 
If New Order releases an album, I'll go buy it.  Bob Mould, Woven Hand, Throwing Muses...I'll buy those too.  I don't expect them to disappoint me, but I go in understanding that the new album might disappoint me.  Or it might be awesome right from the get-go.  Or it might disappoint me at first, but it will get better with additional spins.

There are any number of reasons why an album might not meet my expectations.  One of the key songwriters left the band.  It doesn't sound like the last album.  I'm just not patient enough.  

Or maybe the inspiration isn't there.  At the end of the day, they're artists.  If they're truly inspired, it comes through in the lyrics and in the delivery.  However, if they're just going through the motions to finish up a contract or to put something out because they haven't in a while, the good critics can tell.  And I can tell too, even if I can't quite put my finger on exactly why I don't like something.

"OK Computer" could have been Radiohead's peak, and in a lot of ways, it was.  Although they haven't put out an album better than that one, they haven't tried to replicate that formula, and the different roads they have traveled along have thankfully been more than satisfying.

However, after the terrific, bouncy, emotional "Simpatico!", Velocity Girl's follow up, "Gilded Stars and Jealous Hearts" really wasn't up to that previous standard.  Now, Velocity Girl wasn't Radiohead.  They did not have the technical chops that Radiohead was able to use to modify their sound at will.  VG was a perfectly decent indie-pop band with good songwriting and fairly tight playing.  The biggest problem with "Gilded Stars" was probably Sarah Shannon's vocals.  She just didn't sound like she was into it.  Even on more upbeat tracks like "Go Coastal", she she just sounded tired and uninterested.  Maybe there was more to the tracks that I missed, but her boredom was contagious - I couldn't get into it either.  "It's Not for You" is one of the better tracks on the album, and a reminder that the album could have been better, although maybe it meant that they were ready to split anyway.

No comments:

Post a Comment