Sunday, May 22, 2016

"Buddy Holly" - Weezer

Logically, I should like Weezer, or at least I should have liked them at the time of this release in the mid-'90s.  The grungy sound, the playful atonality, the smart videos, the unabashed geekiness...hey, I was a white middle-class twenty-something...it was basically meant for me.

For the longest time, I chalked it up to me not "getting it".  Then after a while I realized, I did get it - I just didn't like it.  I don't think it was a matter of it hitting too close to home.  Yes, I was a geek at the time, and in some ways I still am.  (I write a music blog.  Doesn't exactly scream "casanova".)  But that wasn't it.  

I didn't go around bellowing "Weezer sucks" like it was a badge of honor for me to dislike a hip band, although I did it with other bands.  I would take shots at easy targets on popular radio.  I think the reason I didn't do that with Weezer was that I just didn't understand why most people liked them, and I didn't.  In the end, I guess I just didn't put much thought into it, so I never talked about them.  When other people brought them up or played them, I didn't complain, though I might have rolled my eyes a little.  

"Buddy Holly" is a fun song.  It gives you geeks trying to sound cool with '90s-era jargon right off the bat.  It gives you odd name-checks like the titular tragic rock star and, for some reason, Mary Tyler Moore.  The band (courtesy of director Spike Jonze) even polished it with an absolutely classic video featuring the band playing onstage in lettermen sweaters at Arnold's Restaurant, the setting of the classic sitcom "Happy Days" and seamlessly blended with original episodes to look like they were there at the time of the original show.  Adorable.

And did it make me like the song?  No.  Has it grown on me over time, like Uncle Tupelo and the Velvet Underground?  No.  Have I liked any of their songs, ever?  No.

And that's OK.  No one is supposed to like every worthwhile song, or even album, even if they appreciate the effort.  Art is weird in that way.  You may not like something you mathematically should like.  Sometimes it'll grow on you, but you cannot predict when or if that will happen.

I don't usually like writing about stuff I don't like, because I'm afraid of bashing it in an non-constructive fashion.  When Homer was a food critic in an episode of "The Simpsons" a while back, he got a little carried away with how popular he was and started bashing restaurants, but his daughter Lisa advised him to dial it down because he was "being mean for no reason".  Hopefully, reading this post, you will gather that I haven't given up on trying to like them, because I do respect them.  

Sunday, May 8, 2016

"Cold to See Clear" - Nada Surf

A recurring theme in these posts is me trying to find songs that describe what it's like to love music as much as I love it.  Whereas the previously blogged Jimmy Eat World song did this in terms of name-checking bands and songs, here's one that I found that is a bit more whimsical about the subject.

I have a pretty large music collection, now mostly in mp3 form.  My wife once asked me why I'm always listening to new things, posing me a how-much-is-enough question.  My answer was simple, even if she probably didn't appreciate it.  Even though my affinity for a given song can be fleeting at any given time, I hold a belief that the song I will love the most in my life is a song I probably haven't heard yet.  So I'm still looking...and listening.  

I go backwards (emusic.com, local library) and forwards (CMJ.com/mixtape, All Songs Considered) constantly.  I keep going back to the older stuff to understand where newer songs and styles get their influences, and there's always room to go deeper.  I never heard of the Pop Group until reading the 33 1/3 book on The Minutemen's Double Nickels on the Dime.  No one talked about them when I was in college, and I was entrenched in the trade publications then.  

I still go forward as well, even though it's much less predictable.  See, since the Kinks' heyday is behind them (just go with me on this), if I never really listened to the Kinks, I could go to allmusic.com, read capsule reviews (that have been written and mulled over and re-written over many years) of each of their albums, and pretty much know what I'm getting into.  Some of the newer reviews run the risk of missing the mark or missing the boat as part of a movement or style.  Not that I'm advocating pigeonholing anyone, but as a listener that is getting to the age where lots of newer stuff sounds the same, it just takes a lot more patience.

And this one, I almost missed.  Those lovable scamps on NPR's "All Songs Considered" played it a few months ago, and I heard it once or twice on Sirius XM channel 35 or 36, but I didn't pay enough attention to it.  Then I took the time to listen to it. 

I always liked certain songs from Nada Surf, but not enough to buy a whole album.  At the time, I assumed their MTV hit "Popular" was a one-off, and by the time they released 1998's The Proximity Effect, they had re-branded themselves as a smart pop-rock band with powerful and beautiful vocals.  "Mother's Day" was still a biting track, much more direct and ferocious lyrically, but with the leadoff track "Hyperspace", they clearly had other aspirations.

My monthly CMJ compilations kept me up with them for years, but, again, it was only one song at a time, and just wouldn't buy the whole album.  Emusic.com was nice enough to reward me with a few extra albums one month, and I dove in and bought their latest offering, You Know Who You Are.  I played the opening cut, "Cold to See Clear".

The vocals kick in with the first bar of music, and it glides along briefly until the first chorus:  "Whatever I do, the radio took me."  It had me.  Ever since I was a teenager in my room, pacing back and forth, singing along with the songs, dreaming of being in a band, expending energy created by the seemingly limitless frustration of being a teenager, music has taken me wherever I agreed to let it.  (Note:  I know people have struggles that are far more indelibly horrifying than my middle-class upbringing, and their victories mean a lot more than anything I can ever achieve.  But, when I was a teenager, like a lot of kids my age, I was pretty focused on myself.)

"What can we do but listen to stories, wretched or glorious".  I love painful songs - songs that show me I'm not alone in my loneliness.  I love soaring songs - songs where people get out of that frustration and celebrate their victory, even if they are by themselves.  Being ok with yourself as an individual is one of life's great personal triumphs.

"I don't mind if it's raining, I don't mind if it's hard".  You can hit me as hard as you want with whatever your pain is.  I'll listen, and if I can learn something from your pain, that will hopefully make me stronger.

"I don't mind what you're thinking / I don't mind if you're not".  Wherever you go, if you had me with you previously, you can ask me to come with you again.  I will decide whether I want to come.  You can go a completely different direction from before.  As long as you're sincere, there's a good chance I'll come too.  And I may just freakin' love it.