Sunday, December 4, 2016

"Ghost" - Neutral Milk Hotel

In writing this blog on my semi-regular basis, I work on it mainly by listening to music.  I listen to music all the time: on the train back and forth to work, working at home, in my car, cooking...whenever I can listen.  And I have different sources of the music:  mostly stuff I buy on the internet (I got a bunch of extra credits from emusic.com) or record stores, or what I get from my local library.  Depending on what tickles my fancy, I pick up around ten albums at a time and listen to them over the following few months.  Without trying to impress you, but merely inform you, here's a list of what I've listened to this year that I had never listened to before:

ARTIST ALBUM
Agent Orange Living in Darkness
Alvvays Alvvays
Beck Morning Phase
Benny Goodman Live at Carnegie Hall
Bikini Kill Pussy Whipped
Bikini Kill The First Two Records
Bikini Kill The Singles
Bob Mould Patch the Sky
Boss Hog Whiteout
Butthole Surfers Locust Abortion Technician
Dali's Car InGladAloneness (EP)
Dead Heavens Feel Low (Single)
Discharge Hear Nothing, See Nothing, Say Nothing
Eddie and the Hot Rods The Singles Collection
Failure The Heart Is a Monster
Faith No More Sol Invictus
Fin Fang Foom Native Tongue
Green Day Revolution Radio
Guided By Voices The Best of Guided By Voices
Iron & Wine Our Endless Numbered Days
Jello Biafra Jezebel (Single)
Jimmy Eat World Chase This Light
Joe Jackson Fast Forward
Johnny Thunders and the Heartbreakers L.A.M.F.
Low Things We Lost in the Fire
Lush Blind Spot (EP)
Lydia Loveless Real
Mecca Normal Dovetail
Minutemen 3-Way Tie (For Last)
Nada Surf Let Go
Nada Surf Lucky
Nada Surf The Proximity Effect
Nada Surf The Stars Are Indifferent to Astronomy
Nada Surf The Weight Is a Gift
Nada Surf You Know Who You Are
Neutral Milk Hotel In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
New Bomb Turks Destroy-Oh-Boy!
New Bomb Turks Information Highway Revisited
Nurse with Wound Chance Meeting
Original Soundtrack Star Wars - The Force Awakens
PJ Harvey The Hope Six Demolition Project
Psychic TV The Best Ov Psychic TV
Pylon Chomp
Queen Stone Cold Classics
Radiohead A Moon-Shaped Pool
Recoil Unsound Methods
Ryan Adams 1989
Ryan Adams 29
Ryan Adams Demolition
Ryan Adams Easy, Tiger
Ryan Adams Love Is Hell Part 1
Ryan Adams and the Cardinals Cardinology
Ryan Adams and the Cardinals III-IV
Suicide Suicide
Swans Children of God/World of Skin
Swans Filth
The Corin Tucker Band Kill My Blues
The Dismemberment Plan The Ice of Boston (EP)
The Exploited Totally Exploited
The Kinks The Best of - 1964-1971
The Kinks The Kink Kontroversy
The Pop Group For How Much Longer Do We Tolerate Mass Murder?
The Spinanes Manos
The Telescopes As Approved by the Committee
The Telescopes Taste / The Perfect Needle
The Trashcan Sinatras Wild Pendulum
The Young Gods Everybody Knows
Throbbing Gristle 20 Jazz Funk Greats
Vanishing Life Surveillance
Various Artists Dr. Demento 30th Anniversary Collection- Dementia 2000 Disc 1
Various Artists The Peel Sessions - Too Pure
Wilco Schmilco
Wild Flag Wild Flag

Now, I like to give each release a fighting chance, so I listen to each one - in its entirety and in its order - three times.  It's something I started doing when a co-worker started giving me his U2 CDs in the Pop era, telling me I should give them a shot because they weren't as bad as I kept making fun of him for still listening to them at that stage.  (I was right to continue to make fun of him.  They still haven't released anything worthwhile since...well, no one really cares what I think about U2.)  

So it's something I have continued to do for the thousand or so albums I've listened to since that time, and it has worked for me.  And I go backwards and forwards, as you can see.  I can't go in one direction all the time.  It's more interesting for me.  That being said, there are albums that are brutal to listen to even once, let alone three times.  The Swans' early releases, especially the extended versions, are, for lack of a better word, rough.  Really rough.  On the other hand, Vanishing Life's debut warranted even more listens.  Not every one gets just the minimum attention if it's really good.

One of those more appreciated albums was the modern rock classic from Neutral Milk Hotel.  For the initiated, you may be thinking to yourself, he never listened to an album that old before?  You'd be right to think that, and no, I never listened to it before.  This isn't my day job, and I don't have unlimited access and time to listen to music, so for many worthwhile albums, along with "Breaking Bad", I just haven't gotten to them yet.  

In the Aeroplane Over the Sea, I finally did, and I'm very glad I did.  I'm not going to review the album or even my favorite song noted above, here.  Everything positive the critics have said about it is correct.

That's something I confirmed for myself, and that I'll admit to you.  I usually don't have much to add to the professional critiques.  I feel like I do have some interesting perspectives sometimes, though, and I would love to hear if you have anything to say, positive, or negative, about the work I'm putting in here.  If you've been reading, I hope it's giving you something to enjoy, and thank you.

Sunday, November 20, 2016

"Same to You" - Lydia Loveless

Back in August of this year, Lydia Loveless released her third album, Real (fourth if you count The Only Man, which she has all but disavowed).  That same month, she announced tour dates for the northeast US, where I reside, and after checking in with a buddy of mine who is a mutual fan, we agreed to get tickets to go to the Bowery Ballroom show in New York City.

I made sure to get the tickets the day they were released.  Actually, the hour they opened up the box office online.  Why, you ask?  After these three progressively "bigger"-sounding albums, I really felt like this was to be her big crossover/breakthrough.  To me, it wasn't any more apparent that she had truly "arrived" than with the album's opener, "Same to You".

The guitar, bass and drums all kick in with the first note, and the vocals don't wait but 14 seconds before starting up.  Her lover is furious with her.  If she talks back, he'll teach her a lesson, with pain.  This is not unusual for their relationship.  She could leave, but she's afraid she doesn't have enough resources to make it on her own.  Or maybe she just doesn't have the energy.  She's dependent on him, but, if you really don't care about me, the spell you have me under will be broken, and I'll go.

The vocal bridge comes in, and it's a doozy.  Is there anything that can take us back to how we felt when we started this journey?  When I fell for the way you used to look at me?  No?  OK, then just have the decency to let me go, and "wave goodbye".  Then I'll know it's over.

That's when the song turns from from sad to gut-wrenching.  When she belts "just wave goodbye", she holds the last note not just for aural effect, but also as if to hold onto that last syllable as if it was a chess piece after making a move.  You're not sure if you really want to finish the move because you're waiting for some sign from your opponent that you made the right move.  Maybe he still wants her.  Maybe she still wants this life.

Unfortunately for the listener, this struggle ends unresolved, but it has no less power with that known.  Live, the sound was just as lush and piercing as on the record.  

I just wish there were more people around to hear it.  I met my friend to see her at the Bowery Ballroom the other night, and there were less than 300 people there.  I felt really bad, like I should have bought more tickets to help out.  She's not Taylor Swift - she doesn't sing poppy songs, though they are getting more catchy.  Her lyrics though are more profane and contain more serious subject matter, though the heartbreak is universal.  I understand she'll never have the same mass appeal as T-Swift, but she really deserves better. 

I hope that this song isn't a metaphor for her music career.  I want to hear more from her, but she is young enough that she can go do something else and just stop all this if it's not getting her anywhere.  I'm not appealing to people to listen to her out of charity.  I'm just telling you that I love what she does, and she is a rare talent to get her messages across sounding as big as anyone else out there.  I wish her all the good luck in the world.

Sunday, November 6, 2016

"Rise Above" - Black Flag

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fsbvo5GVK10

Back again after another layoff (all the licensing testing I was doing for the past 2 years is over now!), and just in time for the scariest time of year - Election Day.


I was thinking the other day about what makes a good punk (or hardcore) rock song, so I investigated it how most others would these days - I looked it up on the internet.  The first website that came up was a wikiHow page on creating a good punk song.  Wow, was it ever useless.  I mean, I don't know much about writing music, but not only is it written for people who know nothing about punk, but it's also just, well, wrong.  It makes blanket statements like how the drums must always be fast, which is just ridiculous, because how would the drummer be able to keep up that pace for a live show?  (More on that in a future post.)


So I looked at a Quora post, and back in December of last year, author Mike Bowerbank seemed to sum it up fairly well:  


"Find your passion. Channel your outrage. Put it to music."  

https://www.quora.com/How-do-I-write-a-good-punk-song


I'm sure this not the only verse on the subject, but it's actually pretty good.  Missing any one of those three items, and you don't have a punk song.  (I'm equating the notion of a "punk" song and a "hardcore" song for the purposes of this post, even though I'm fully aware that they are significantly different.)


You have to be passionate about it.  If you're not, the conviction you are trying to portray will not come through or in the performance.  Most people can tell the difference.  You can try to mask that lacking by putting a catchy tune underneath it, and people may buy it for the sound, but something that is accessible is not necessarily good.  There are thousands of pop songs that are popular more for the way they sound than for whether the fans of the song believe and connect with the singer.  It's not necessarily useful from any artistic perspective; it's just accessible.  You need to have a clear message, it has to be about something, and you have to truly believe it, or you won't be able to convey it.


You have to have a message.  It must be about something that's important to you, and hopefully to others as well.  If it's too focused on your isolated problem, that no one else can relate to or would be offended by you even bringing it up (e.g. you get mad because the poor people on the street are asking you for money, not because the government is not doing enough to help them).  The government didn't do this, or the government didn't do that...someone is corrupt and took a bribe or caved to corporate interests that made lots of people's lives worse, that sort of thing.  That message must be clear in your music.  Not crystal clear, because a lot of punk bands get by with unintelligible lyrics, but if your message gets out, all the better.


Most music needs actual music.  Now, in the end, it's art, so the fans cannot dictate what you sound like.  You have to decide that for yourself.  It can be slow, or fast, or mid-level speed; it can change speeds; it can have no underlying music and be all vocals...it's up to the artist.  Spoken word technically isn't music, so if if there's no music sheet underlying some instrument, it's more difficult to sell.  But we're talking about punk songs here.  If it's more accessible, you have a better chance of it catching on.  But if you're a true artist, you make it sound however you please and hope that people at least respect it, even if they don't enjoy it.


Let's apply all this to "Rise Above", probably the best overall song from Black Flag, as well as being their most well-known.  Are they passionate?  Hell yes.  At the time it was written in the late 1970s-early 1980s, punk rock was under attack.  It wasn't just the idealists that were after them.  The police were actively seeking out punk shows to put a hurt on the artists as well as anyone else that got in their way.  There are plenty of stories of bands taking their licks from the police during this time, though since they are all one-sided stories, I will not get into any details.  I will only say that the bands often used their music to vent their frustrations.  And they were frustrated.  When the lyrics kick in, it's then-new vocalist Henry Rollins that leads the charge, and after just one phrase, the rest of the band roars, "Rise above! / We're gonna rise above!"  They're announcing that they're all here, standing together, and this matters, at least to them.


Do they have a message?  Oh yeah.  


People that can't do what we do so well put us down in an effort to control and/or stop us.  We have a chance to do something here, and we're taking it.  We're not letting you stop us, and we won't sink to your level.  We'll do it together, because we know the bond makes us stronger.  Want to stop us?  Go ahead - except, our fans know we're right, and you're wrong.  You don't know how to fight both us and our followers.


Does it have music?  Yep.  Kicking off with a surf-guitar riff akin to the Dead Kennedys style, it almost sounds like an emergency vehicle siren before quickly speeding up the tempo to a low-end anthemic riff, and then Rollins and the band let loose the vocals in a call-and-response pattern, with the aforementioned shouted two-line refrain.  That refrain is every bit a classic, and it is repeated throughout the song just like a protest chant.  Any fan of the song will just shout along, and if you're like me, it doesn't matter how old you are.  (It saves some embarrassment if you're by yourself, though, as cops beating up punks is not relatable these days.)


Does every punk song have to follow these guidelines?  Of course not.  Punk artists will not only talk about protest but personal relationships, as their lives can be just as complicated as anyone else's.  They love, they lose, and their home lives can be anywhere from normal to dysfunctional to horrifying.  They were always people too.  
But they found a way to get their emotions out and reach out to others creatively.  You can protest about whatever injustices you feel there are.  This is only one of your options.  




Sunday, July 3, 2016

"Clipped" - Curve

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-loNpejR758&list=RD-loNpejR758#t=161


(Back in August of last year, I penned an ode to brick-and-mortar record stores.  I'm doing so again with this note, as two more stalwarts have bitten the dust.)

A couple of weeks ago, I caught a great documentary on cable called "All Things Must Pass" from director Colin Hanks (yes, that Hanks), which chronicled the rise and fall of Tower Records, which closed its US-based stores in 2006.  Record stores seem to be dropping like flies lately, especially in New York City, where rising rents coupled with the general ease of accessing online music have been spelling doom for almost all of these shops.

Around the corner from the Tower store in the East Village was Other Music, which had opened in 1995 at that location and actually outlasted Tower, staying open until last week.  I never really made it part of my Friday evening jaunts because I was kind of a creature of habit and liked the walking pattern of going to St. Mark's, Tower, skipping Other and the Bleecker stores, stopping at Kim's West and Generation, and then jumping on the train at West 4th to go back home to Brooklyn.

That's not to say I did not start visiting Other after all of these stores shut down.  However, I do not go often - probably three to four times a year.  There are three reasons for this.  First, I have been buying a lot of stuff online.  I have a good job, but I am by no means rich, and I am always looking for deals.  Amazon and eBay had (and still have) ways for you get what you wanted at a price you could live with as long as you could sacrifice holding it in your hand before you bought it.  Second, I got married in 2006.  My hobbies took a hit because we bought an apartment which required some upkeep.  Further to that, my wife does not appreciate music the same way I do, so if we're together, it's never to go shopping for records.  After we had a baby in 2008, whatever time I had to myself at that point had vanished.  Third, and this is horrible, I found that after we moved to New Jersey, the public library in my town has so many CDs that I can borrow for free.  I should stop out of respect for the artists, but I pay too much in property taxes.

I have a little more "me" time now because my wife and daughter share some interests that I do not, so every few months, I get a Friday after work to go wandering in the Village.  I would go to Other Music, which had a bright, well-designed layout, filled with new and old music and smiling employee faces.  Every time I went, I would find a bunch of stuff that I either wanted or kinda wanted, and if the prices were right, they were mine, added to my ever-growing library.  I thought I was helping, but I wasn't doing nearly enough.  This is not to say that I, myself, could have spent the extra thousands of dollars per month necessary to keep the place continually profitable, but I was sacrificing being able to visit a store for the sake of my wallet.

I had continued to skip the Bleecker stores.  Rebel Rebel is another store that closed in the last week, this one after 28 years, and though I did not frequent it, it holds a special place in my heart for being the place I used to go to for imports back in the '90s.  Back in 1991, the woman in college I was dating took me after class one Friday night.  I had never been record shopping in Manhattan before, so I read up beforehand and knew what I wanted.  After scouring through the used bins at Sounds and grabbing a couple of decent-looking Killing Joke LPs, we walked all the way over to Bleecker, and to Rebel Rebel.  I remember the store looking pristine (it was only three years old at the time - forgive me if I am remembering any of this incorrectly); the racks were new, and there was plenty of space to move around.  LPs were on the left; CDs on the right, just past the cash register.  This changed over time, as the boxes upon boxes of media took over almost all of the walking space in the store, but what I am describing here is how I will choose to remember it.

Three things had just recently been released that I really wanted.  As New Order, one of my favorites at the time, was on a sort of hiatus, Electronic and Revenge left room for Stephen and Gillian to form The Other Two, an unsurprisingly synth-based pop project pleasing to the ears, and the import-only 7", "Tasty Fish", was a perfectly decent buy.  The second was a band that was part of the Mancunian movement at the time, though they were less popular than the Stone Roses, Charlatans or Happy Mondays.  New Fast Automatic Daffodils had made no splash with their first album, Pigeonhole, but the remix of the single "Get Better" was exhilarating enough for me to want to grab their next non-album single, "All Over My Face".  Like most of their releases before 1992's great Body Exit Mind, the single found them capable but the music still slight.

The third was the one I was desperate for.  Curve was one of the most exciting bands of the day (for me, anyway), and certainly my favorite of the inappropriately-labeled "shoegazer" bands.  I loved their previous two EPs, Blindfold and Frozen, and I had read in CMJ that they just dropped a new one called Cherry.  

After finding all three of my "wants" in the store, I purchased them and brought them home.  "Clipped" was the first song on the Curve EP, and it did not disappoint.  Taking the danceable backdrops from Blindfold and melding them with the more full-sounding Frozen gave "Clipped" a fantastic urgency, and the commanding vocals, though still at times impenetrable, were even more compelling and seductive than anything they had done to date.  One of my best finds ever.

Look, I know this does nothing, and that I am only writing about this in a nostalgic sense.  I have no right to tell anyone to go out and buy records to save physical stores, because I don't do it enough myself.  Maybe I thought that my love for music was fleeting, that 20 years ago I did not think I would be as into it as I am now.  I was wrong on many counts, and I am sorry for not doing enough. 

The other night, my wife and I went to see The Stone Roses at Madison Square Garden in Manhattan, which was a great show.  Now, we listen to Sirius XM First Wave and Lithium in the car all the time, and my daughter has some favorites (Human League, Madness, even Ryan Adams when I play my iPod).  My wife said to me at one point during the show, "You know, I think our daughter would like this."  I hope it's not too late.  I want her to still be able to experience staring at a wall of vinyl and saying to herself, I wonder if I'd like that... 

Sunday, June 19, 2016

"Red Planet" - Alvvays


I was thinking about some of the horrible events this past week, about losing loved ones, and this song came up on my mp3 player.  Not my favorite song on the album, as "Archie, Marry Me" should stand as a modern rock classic in due time, but this is a striking song just the same, and in keeping with my purpose here.

I was thinking how the song belies what can happen to a person after a prolonged bout with stress, possibly created by grief.  The song plays like an obscure '80s synth band fronted and slowed down by Nina Nastasia.  (I'm not trying to be pretentious.  If you know who she is, you hopefully see what I'm saying.)  

The song hums along with a backdrop of haunting reverse synths and very light percussion, and it starts with lead singer Molly Rankin talking about being on the "red planet" for almost 20 years.  The amount of time is arbitrary, as progress dealing with grief is subjective.  It could feel like 20 years.  She is alone.  She could have people with her, but you wouldn't know it because, at least in the present tense, she doesn't talk about anyone but herself.  

She dreams of being with and holding her lost loved one, but whatever the tragic event was that separated them, it continually interrupts and destroys the fantasy, leaving her to clean up the remnants and try to move on, though it's obvious she hasn't.  

She talks about other memories, of how she met the object of this affection, and unfortunately how she pictures those memories has warped over time.  She accepts these changes as the norm, and that they will not stop her from feeling this loss.  Nothing will will distract her from this grief, no matter whatever else is going on around her.

The song's chorus is a '70s-style, Nicolette Larson-soundalike, calling into the wind that she's still waiting for her loved one to return though almost simultaneously admitting that she knows it will never happen.  Then she talks about painting pictures of how her life was before the event, and how strange it was for her to do that.

She sings, "I painted all these pictures of earth, but that's unusual to you."  She does not clarify who the "you" is.  It may leave the listener wondering to whom she is actually talking.  She could be talking to a therapist, which is a hopeful ending, because she is trying to find a positive way out.  She could be talking to the loved one, though if that is the case, it seems to be a one-sided conversation, as there is not even a documented reaction, let alone a response from that person.  Or, she could just be talking to herself, repeating circles and patterns, and just not getting any better.

As the album's closer, it leaves the listener with a sense of incompleteness and almost dread.  I'm rooting for her, though.   

Sunday, May 22, 2016

"Buddy Holly" - Weezer

Logically, I should like Weezer, or at least I should have liked them at the time of this release in the mid-'90s.  The grungy sound, the playful atonality, the smart videos, the unabashed geekiness...hey, I was a white middle-class twenty-something...it was basically meant for me.

For the longest time, I chalked it up to me not "getting it".  Then after a while I realized, I did get it - I just didn't like it.  I don't think it was a matter of it hitting too close to home.  Yes, I was a geek at the time, and in some ways I still am.  (I write a music blog.  Doesn't exactly scream "casanova".)  But that wasn't it.  

I didn't go around bellowing "Weezer sucks" like it was a badge of honor for me to dislike a hip band, although I did it with other bands.  I would take shots at easy targets on popular radio.  I think the reason I didn't do that with Weezer was that I just didn't understand why most people liked them, and I didn't.  In the end, I guess I just didn't put much thought into it, so I never talked about them.  When other people brought them up or played them, I didn't complain, though I might have rolled my eyes a little.  

"Buddy Holly" is a fun song.  It gives you geeks trying to sound cool with '90s-era jargon right off the bat.  It gives you odd name-checks like the titular tragic rock star and, for some reason, Mary Tyler Moore.  The band (courtesy of director Spike Jonze) even polished it with an absolutely classic video featuring the band playing onstage in lettermen sweaters at Arnold's Restaurant, the setting of the classic sitcom "Happy Days" and seamlessly blended with original episodes to look like they were there at the time of the original show.  Adorable.

And did it make me like the song?  No.  Has it grown on me over time, like Uncle Tupelo and the Velvet Underground?  No.  Have I liked any of their songs, ever?  No.

And that's OK.  No one is supposed to like every worthwhile song, or even album, even if they appreciate the effort.  Art is weird in that way.  You may not like something you mathematically should like.  Sometimes it'll grow on you, but you cannot predict when or if that will happen.

I don't usually like writing about stuff I don't like, because I'm afraid of bashing it in an non-constructive fashion.  When Homer was a food critic in an episode of "The Simpsons" a while back, he got a little carried away with how popular he was and started bashing restaurants, but his daughter Lisa advised him to dial it down because he was "being mean for no reason".  Hopefully, reading this post, you will gather that I haven't given up on trying to like them, because I do respect them.  

Sunday, May 8, 2016

"Cold to See Clear" - Nada Surf

A recurring theme in these posts is me trying to find songs that describe what it's like to love music as much as I love it.  Whereas the previously blogged Jimmy Eat World song did this in terms of name-checking bands and songs, here's one that I found that is a bit more whimsical about the subject.

I have a pretty large music collection, now mostly in mp3 form.  My wife once asked me why I'm always listening to new things, posing me a how-much-is-enough question.  My answer was simple, even if she probably didn't appreciate it.  Even though my affinity for a given song can be fleeting at any given time, I hold a belief that the song I will love the most in my life is a song I probably haven't heard yet.  So I'm still looking...and listening.  

I go backwards (emusic.com, local library) and forwards (CMJ.com/mixtape, All Songs Considered) constantly.  I keep going back to the older stuff to understand where newer songs and styles get their influences, and there's always room to go deeper.  I never heard of the Pop Group until reading the 33 1/3 book on The Minutemen's Double Nickels on the Dime.  No one talked about them when I was in college, and I was entrenched in the trade publications then.  

I still go forward as well, even though it's much less predictable.  See, since the Kinks' heyday is behind them (just go with me on this), if I never really listened to the Kinks, I could go to allmusic.com, read capsule reviews (that have been written and mulled over and re-written over many years) of each of their albums, and pretty much know what I'm getting into.  Some of the newer reviews run the risk of missing the mark or missing the boat as part of a movement or style.  Not that I'm advocating pigeonholing anyone, but as a listener that is getting to the age where lots of newer stuff sounds the same, it just takes a lot more patience.

And this one, I almost missed.  Those lovable scamps on NPR's "All Songs Considered" played it a few months ago, and I heard it once or twice on Sirius XM channel 35 or 36, but I didn't pay enough attention to it.  Then I took the time to listen to it. 

I always liked certain songs from Nada Surf, but not enough to buy a whole album.  At the time, I assumed their MTV hit "Popular" was a one-off, and by the time they released 1998's The Proximity Effect, they had re-branded themselves as a smart pop-rock band with powerful and beautiful vocals.  "Mother's Day" was still a biting track, much more direct and ferocious lyrically, but with the leadoff track "Hyperspace", they clearly had other aspirations.

My monthly CMJ compilations kept me up with them for years, but, again, it was only one song at a time, and just wouldn't buy the whole album.  Emusic.com was nice enough to reward me with a few extra albums one month, and I dove in and bought their latest offering, You Know Who You Are.  I played the opening cut, "Cold to See Clear".

The vocals kick in with the first bar of music, and it glides along briefly until the first chorus:  "Whatever I do, the radio took me."  It had me.  Ever since I was a teenager in my room, pacing back and forth, singing along with the songs, dreaming of being in a band, expending energy created by the seemingly limitless frustration of being a teenager, music has taken me wherever I agreed to let it.  (Note:  I know people have struggles that are far more indelibly horrifying than my middle-class upbringing, and their victories mean a lot more than anything I can ever achieve.  But, when I was a teenager, like a lot of kids my age, I was pretty focused on myself.)

"What can we do but listen to stories, wretched or glorious".  I love painful songs - songs that show me I'm not alone in my loneliness.  I love soaring songs - songs where people get out of that frustration and celebrate their victory, even if they are by themselves.  Being ok with yourself as an individual is one of life's great personal triumphs.

"I don't mind if it's raining, I don't mind if it's hard".  You can hit me as hard as you want with whatever your pain is.  I'll listen, and if I can learn something from your pain, that will hopefully make me stronger.

"I don't mind what you're thinking / I don't mind if you're not".  Wherever you go, if you had me with you previously, you can ask me to come with you again.  I will decide whether I want to come.  You can go a completely different direction from before.  As long as you're sincere, there's a good chance I'll come too.  And I may just freakin' love it.



Sunday, April 24, 2016

"Hit Song" - Peter Murphy

I know the first four Peter Murphy solo albums pretty well.  If I were to rank them from most favorite to least favorite:  1. Deep (1989), 2. Love Hysteria (1988), 3. Should the World Fail to Fall Apart (1986), 4. Holy Smoke (1992).  Now, this is not an unusual arc, but every career is different, and it always bothered me hat I couldn't put my finger on why I liked certain albums more than others.

Then it came to me.  The first and last one weren't spooky enough.  Love Hysteria and Deep definitely had their lighter moments, the most obvious being the classic single, "Indigo Eyes".  However, they also had some capably-crafted haunting moments, like "All Night Long" and the almost Top-40 hit "Cuts You Up".  

Now, these songs were not cloning or even recalling Bauhaus.  His former band's piercing, jagged riffs were few and far between in his solo works.  These were moody tracks that were heartfelt at the same time, letting you in just enough, but still keeping you far enough away so that you knew you weren't exactly inside.  (The video for "All Night Long" had Murphy partly in shadows and hiding behind sheets, making it difficult for the viewer to focus on him.)  Murphy's voice was warm and flowing.  It always had an air of pretentiousness, but I can't imagine anyone thinking he would have toned down his crooning that much after moving from the quintessential Gothic band to a solo career. 

The biggest issue with the four albums is that they're all choppy and inconsistent.  The songs are just stronger on the middle two.  The first album was a little too mechanical-sounding at times, but this was forgivable for a first solo album, where he was trying to differentiate himself not only from Bauhaus, but also from Murphy's side project with Japan's Mick Karn called Dali's Car.  

Holy Smoke was a different story.  I loved Deep, and I was really looking forward to this follow-up.  It just never really gelled.  It's not fair to ask for a "Cuts You Up 2", but there needs to be an air of sincerity.  I just didn't get a sense of that from this album.  Songs like "The Sweetest Drop" and "Keep Me from Harm" are strong enough, but like Phil Collins' "But Seriously", he pretty much lost his eerie side.  And a song like "Hit Song", though it may have been cheeky, was still annoyingly obvious, with its slow drum machine march and incongruous, intermittent vibratto.

Look, I get that each artist has to follow his/her own path, and far be it from me to tell anyone how to run their career, especially a career in music.  To his credit, Murphy had several solo albums after that one, and he never really re-adopted the "Gothic-lite" delivery technique, getting even a little more poppy.  But I'm human.  I wanted "Cuts You Up 2".  Doesn't make me a bad person.


Sunday, April 10, 2016

"Sea" - Codeine

This is going to seem like a weird lead-in.  One of the things that was so impressive about the movie "The Birdcage" (the American version of the French play and film, "La Cage Aux Folles"), other than the manic, in-your-face acting, was the one lead that didn't play his usual manic self.  The late, great Robin Williams was incredibly controlled in that performance, letting loose only for a couple of quick outbursts.  Otherwise, his character was the "straight man" (who also happened to be gay).

Control is a very human quality, and not everyone has it.  When I was in college, I had listened to the Codeine releases Barely Real and The White Birch, but other than "Realize" and "Tom", the tortoise-paced records didn't make enough of an impression on me back then.

I had some extra credits on emusic.com recently, and I decided to buy all three of their records (including their first, "Frigid Stars LP").  After listening to them all the way through a couple of times, it almost got to be unbearable.  It's just too slow.  Now, I know their catalog should be treated like candy:  not a whole bag in one sitting.  You sorta can't see the forest for the trees after a while.  The same applies to their short history.  If you have a whole bowl of Skittles, the first one you eat will be more or less the same as the last one, save for the color and flavor, incidental to the general chemical mixture.  Codeine's catalog followed a similar aesthetic:  the pace is slow throughout almost every song.  The lyrics and bars change from song to song, but they all just crawl.  All of them, from beginning to end.  Although they can dramatically change volume mid-track, they do not succumb to a tendency to succumb to bursts of speed (like Slint, who sound very much like Codeine at times, and vice versa, since they both recorded around the same time).

You'd have thought that by the third release, "The White Birch", they may have wanted to try a somewhat different approach, mix it up a little.  I mean, it's only human for a band to want to rock out once in a while, right?  You'd have been wrong.  "Sea" opens the album with their standard low bass, light percussion, slowly-strummed jangly guitar (like Johnny Marr at 1/8th speed), and whispered, almost drowned-out vocals.  Most impressively, guitarist and vocalist Steve Immerwahr, takes the phrase "I understand" and drags it out for about 25 seconds.  He holds the third syllable for about 13 seconds at a low note before pausing for a few more seconds and releasing, at a higher note and a glorious crescendo, "stannnnnnnnnnnd" (yes, kinda like the R.E.M. song, but nowhere near as irritating).  I knew what you were half-expecting, and I didn't quite give it to you, but I wanted you to know I understood the difference.  He does this twice in the song, changing nothing the second time.

It took me a few listens to pick up on that, and hey, I still don't love them, but gosh-darnit do I respect the hell out of it.

Sunday, March 13, 2016

"American Dreaming" - Dead Can Dance

(Sorry for missing my last usual bi-weekly post.  I was studying for a test.  I passed.  Yay!)

One of the most interesting features of Dead Can Dance's live shows is that they normally play unreleased songs.  I don't mean B-sides, but completely unreleased, unheard songs.  When they released their first official live album, Toward the Within, in 1994, the centerpiece was "American Dreaming", a Brendan Perry-sung piece of soaring beauty.  

In referencing DCD songs, I usually feel the need to note which of Perry or his partner, Lisa Gerrard, sang the particular track.  As anyone familiar with the band knows, there is a stark contrast between the two vocal styles and oftentimes the musical backdrop.  Where Gerrard's songs usually have a decidedly chamber music feel, Perry's tend to be more accessible, though pallid, with a Gothic theme.  Both voices sound other-worldly.  Gerrard sounds like a cherub singing through the vocal chords of a crow.  To say that she was born to do this provides about as much insight as saying that a salmon was born to swim.  The same goes for Perry, whose full, commanding yet soothing voice flows thick like a great magic marker.

The song announces itself with a bleed-in of fluttering butterflies from the previous song, "I Can See Now", also a previously unknown song,  Then comes the acoustic guitar, a rare sound on a Dead Can Dance record.  Perry's vocals chime in, and the song fully takes off.  It's far from the first conventional-sounding song of theirs, but it's definitely the biggest-sounding.

I don't know if the well-engineered live recording enhanced the original version of the song, but since it was the first and only version I heard, I don't really want to hear the original version.  I don't care.  It's like Cheap Trick's "I Want You to Want Me".  I have only heard the live version.  I don't need the original.  The live version is plenty energetic and enervating, so I'm good with that.  There's gotta be a reason no one plays the original version on the radio.

In the mid-2000s, Dead Can Dance released a set of live recordings from a recent reunion tour.  On the one album that I bought, they included a song called "Crescent", which, of course, was previously unreleased.  It's almost ten minutes long, but fully engaging.  

Perry subsequently released a studio version of it on his second solo album, Ark.  I didn't like the studio version.  The live version felt so much more organic and urgent, where the album version was more synthesizer-heavy, and as a result, cold.  It still sounds good, but, just not important.  

Is there a point to this rant?  Well, I just don't know if there is answer to the question of whether I'm a bad music fan if I just want to stick to one version of a song.  I don't want to double-up and take up extra space on my mp3 player.  Call me weird, but...oh, you probably already do.

Sunday, February 14, 2016

"Can't Change Me" - Lydia Loveless

A mission statement in a song, if ever there was one.  The second track on her second proper album (her first, The Only Man, has been all but disowned by her) stomps in with the dead stare of a young Fiona Apple without any of the sentimentality.  Ms. Loveless has arrived, complete with an album cover image of a seated woman drinking out of the spout of what looks like a can of kerosene.  And she spits out as much at least as much as she takes in, both literally and figuratively.  When she's not vomiting after a rough night out, she's spewing fire.

Does each artist have to have a statement of purpose, or a song that truly defines their purpose?  Of course not.  Most artists and bands don't have their purpose fully realized by the time they're ready to go out and play, and even if they do, it's very often that that mission will change over time, and often.  It is the rare artist that is successful without changing.  The world changes all the time, people's tastes change too, and whether it's in purpose or sound, most artists need to keep up.  It's not necessarily a bad thing unless an artist is simply changing aesthetically to pander to the audience and not really adapting his or her sound so that it's still "them".

It's easy, and sometimes unfair to pick on chameleons.  Bowie was a chameleon, at least in the 1980s, seemingly the decade when audiences were most easily amused.  If you played rock, you had to make sure you threw in a few soft synthesizer hooks into your songs to make them sound like today.   Now, he was very successful, so it's hard to argue the formula, but it can be frustrating to longtime fans and confusing to others who wonder if they are only changing their sound to reach or maintain a large audience as opposed to expanding their repertoire while staying true to their ideals.

Other artists change their sound as they mature.  They understand more about the creative process, and they can put their experience in the writing and recording processes to make their sound more cohesive.  The first song I heard from Lydia Loveless was "Really Wanna See You Again" from her 2014 almost-breakthrough album Somewhere Else, and I fell in love with it right away.  The tracks oscillate between Americana and straight-up rock, with pull-no-punches lyrics and a swagger that would leave an "Episode IV" Han Solo speechless.

I read up on the other releases, and I wanted in.  I went backwards, and listened to her Boy Crazy EP, released just a few months before that album.  More of the same, except speedier, but never in a rush.  Then I went back to Indestructible Machine, and it was all over for me.  I was hooked.  Much like Uncle Tupelo's early recordings were much more immediate and pounding than later work like the more expansive swan song Anodyne, Ms. Loveless' first album finds her trying to strike a balance among her honky tonk inspirations, (almost too) honest ballads and all-out rockers.  As an album, it holds together well and is very mature lyrically for someone in her early 20s at the time it was recorded.  "Can't Change Me" is the star of the show, however.  It grabs you by the throat and throttles you for four minutes, leaving you just enough air in your windpipes to keep the auditory functions working.

The song starts out with, ironically, what almost seems like an apology:  I don't quite remember what I said or who I said it to, but if you say that I said it to you, I won't debate it with you.  But I'm not going to take it back either.  So Ms. Loveless really doesn't apologize so much as compare her own behavior to that of a tiger that, for some reason, you thought you could trust in a room alone with your best dry-aged ribeye.  You misread the situation.

She goes on that you can say whatever you want about her, whether to her face or behind her back.  It won't bother her.  She won't become anyone else because she's not affected by what you say.  Only you will be affected by it because it apparently gets you so riled up.  

Take that aspect, add in her little antagonistic conversations with Jesus Christ, and the song starts to take on another dimension.  She may be the devil.  Nothing will change her.  If you want to play, you will be changed.  She mocks Jesus.  When she visits Earth, she has to fit in to tempt the good, but being good is killing her inside.  

Maybe that's thin, but the song isn't.  It's a full-on beast, and although no other individual track on the album can match its intensity, the attitude permeates throughout the rest of the songs, and it's a fantastic start to a still-evolving, but never compromising, canon thus far.

Sunday, January 31, 2016

"Keep On Rockin' It" - Luscious Jackson

I was driving from Brooklyn, where i lived, into Manhattan, to go see my then-girlfriend when I first heard Luscious Jackson.  It was a Friday evening in the fall of 1992 during the legendary "New Afternoon Show" on WNYU, the radio station of New York University in New York City.
   
I didn't listen to WNYU that often.  Three reasons for this.  First, they shared the frequency with another school, so they only had a certain amount of airtime per day.  Second, the "New Afternoon Show" was only on weekdays in the late afternoon for a few hours per day, not all day and night like the pre-eminent modern rock station, WDRE, so you had to remember when it was on, AND you had to be in the right physical location with a good antenna to listen.  (As I am fond of reminding everyone, during my college days in the early 1990s, there was no Internet, so you couldn't listen from just anywhere.)  Other times were slotted for even more specialized programming, so that show, and "Crucial Chaos", the hardcore-punk show on Thursday nights were really the only shows that did me any good to listen to.  Third, it wasn't an easy listen.  

I'll explain that last point a little further.  Now, back in 1992, I was still a relative newcomer to the modern rock scene.  I had a pretty good grasp of the easy stuff, which was most of WDRE's playlists - Depeche Mode, New Order, the Smiths, etc.  I was a junior in college by that point, and I had increased my knowledge tenfold since joining the radio station at St. John's University.  However, NAS was an entirely different animal.  They were way ahead of the curve.  They didn't play Depeche Mode.  It wasn't that only non-conventional music made their playlist, but, for example, the Jon Spencer Blues Explosion was their version of Depeche Mode, and even that band wasn't immune from the downstream effects of MTV fame.  They were NYC royalty, but JSBX was getting a little too popular, and they were probably one "Total Request Live" appearance from being dropped from rotation on the NAS.

WNYU was proudly playing Negativland, the Moles and Babyland in regular rotation.  Now, that was stuff you'd never hear, especially on WDRE, who was never far from oblivion (they eventually folded a few years later), so understandably they couldn't be THAT adventurous with music that abrasive and inaccessible.  

That takes us back to Luscious Jackson.  On this particular night, as I was cruising up the FDR Drive toward the East Village in my unimpressive but reliable silver 1984 Nissan Sentra, the DJ was geeking out about this new band called Luscious Jackson and how they got them into their studio for an interview (and maybe a recording session; I can't remember).  The song in regular rotation was "Daughters of the KAOS", the first single from the band's debut In Search of Manny EP, but at this moment, they were playing another cut from the EP, "Keep on Rockin' It".  I'm not going to tell you much about the band's history.  You probably already know about their connections with the Beastie Boys and their eventual major-label deal and Top 40 hit, so I'll save some space here and just tell you about my reaction to this song.  

It was one of those "Holy S***!" moments that can happen when appreciating an artistic work - in this case, a song.  Gabby Glaser's reggae-sounding rap-rhyming contrasted with Jill Cuniff's fluid choruses and calypso bassline, Vivian Trimble glittery-crystal keyboards, and Kate Schellenbach's understated but driving snare slaps are a force to behold.  All of it delivered with a stare - not an upturned lip in the bunch, and all of it just unpolished enough that it was as authentic NYC as a dimly-lit Bowery street.  

The first five of the seven tracks on that EP are all like that.  (The last two were a little weaker, but easily forgivable.)  The selfish me wanted everything they ever put out to be that good.  Realistic me knew that just wouldn't be possible.  Art is an incredibly fragile thing.  It's not supposed to follow a logical structure, and it certainly doesn't know how to strike that kind of chord in one person (like me) the same way time and time again.

Luckily for a fan like me, they put out two great full-length albums before they faltered a little and then wisely went their separate ways.  (I had no hard feelings about the third album Electric Honey, though, as my wife and I used leadoff cut "Nervous Breakthrough" for the wedding party to walk into during our reception.)   Their 2013 comeback, Magic Hour, was anything but a weak attempt at nostalgia, with the ladies romping through full-steam and doing themselves, and NYC, proud.  They'll never be as recognized as their original label heads, but they have as much to do with the lower east side pre-re-gentrification NYC scene (and the progression of all-female bands) as almost anyone else.