Sunday, March 13, 2016

"American Dreaming" - Dead Can Dance

(Sorry for missing my last usual bi-weekly post.  I was studying for a test.  I passed.  Yay!)

One of the most interesting features of Dead Can Dance's live shows is that they normally play unreleased songs.  I don't mean B-sides, but completely unreleased, unheard songs.  When they released their first official live album, Toward the Within, in 1994, the centerpiece was "American Dreaming", a Brendan Perry-sung piece of soaring beauty.  

In referencing DCD songs, I usually feel the need to note which of Perry or his partner, Lisa Gerrard, sang the particular track.  As anyone familiar with the band knows, there is a stark contrast between the two vocal styles and oftentimes the musical backdrop.  Where Gerrard's songs usually have a decidedly chamber music feel, Perry's tend to be more accessible, though pallid, with a Gothic theme.  Both voices sound other-worldly.  Gerrard sounds like a cherub singing through the vocal chords of a crow.  To say that she was born to do this provides about as much insight as saying that a salmon was born to swim.  The same goes for Perry, whose full, commanding yet soothing voice flows thick like a great magic marker.

The song announces itself with a bleed-in of fluttering butterflies from the previous song, "I Can See Now", also a previously unknown song,  Then comes the acoustic guitar, a rare sound on a Dead Can Dance record.  Perry's vocals chime in, and the song fully takes off.  It's far from the first conventional-sounding song of theirs, but it's definitely the biggest-sounding.

I don't know if the well-engineered live recording enhanced the original version of the song, but since it was the first and only version I heard, I don't really want to hear the original version.  I don't care.  It's like Cheap Trick's "I Want You to Want Me".  I have only heard the live version.  I don't need the original.  The live version is plenty energetic and enervating, so I'm good with that.  There's gotta be a reason no one plays the original version on the radio.

In the mid-2000s, Dead Can Dance released a set of live recordings from a recent reunion tour.  On the one album that I bought, they included a song called "Crescent", which, of course, was previously unreleased.  It's almost ten minutes long, but fully engaging.  

Perry subsequently released a studio version of it on his second solo album, Ark.  I didn't like the studio version.  The live version felt so much more organic and urgent, where the album version was more synthesizer-heavy, and as a result, cold.  It still sounds good, but, just not important.  

Is there a point to this rant?  Well, I just don't know if there is answer to the question of whether I'm a bad music fan if I just want to stick to one version of a song.  I don't want to double-up and take up extra space on my mp3 player.  Call me weird, but...oh, you probably already do.

No comments:

Post a Comment