Sunday, March 22, 2015

"Daddy Was a Real Good Dancer" - The Dismemberment Plan

Comebacks.  Some work, but most don't.  Sleater-Kinney, obviously awesome (I'll try to stop gushing over them).  Gang of Four, good, but not great.  Some of it is interesting, but it hardly seems vital.  Helmet had a comeback that started out OK but ended up sounding downright depressing.

If you are getting back together for the money, that's one thing.  You had a good following, a few albums that you can still sell, you weren't able to do anything else that fulfilling or lucrative, and your band still gets along, kinda. But can you still come up with the same magic? 

OK maybe that doesn't matter.  You're cashing in a little, serving those who don't expect more from you than to go through the motions as long as you get them off by playing decent enough versions of the hits.  You can play Jones Beach every summer at the very least.

But then again, if you only developed a cult following as a college radio band, you won't fill stadiums, especially if your band hasn't come into a Slint-like "Oh, man, I wish I had seen them when they were around" status during your hiatus.  That's when you do need that "magic" to come back.  If it doesn't, you wind up sounding like a really weak version of your former self, and even your dedicated fans will just miss the old you and wish you had stayed retired.

It's a little extreme, I know, and it's sort of unfair to criticize a band who created and released to the public a new piece that is simply meant to be enjoyed.  I just wish it was better.



Sunday, March 15, 2015

"A Strange Kind of Love" - Peter Murphy

There are a lot of "what ifs" when it comes to the career of an artist like Peter Murphy.  What if he had his act together in the early-'80s, and Bauhaus didn't break up?  What if he had the foresight to try to maintain his new and/or re-affirmed fanbase of disaffected '90s youth by releasing a follow-up that progressed from "Deep" rather than a lame, love-y follow up to "Love Hysteria"?  What if he decided not to get in that car?

One possibility I've thought about over the years is what would have happened if they had picked a better single as a follow-up to "Cuts You Up".  "Deep" is by far Murphy's best solo effort, and "Cuts You Up" was almost a throwback to Bauhaus, with Murphy's signature brooding croon, which was probably purposefully though undoubtedly missing from his post-Bauhaus efforts.

"Deep" was not a perfect album, of course, but it did show that Murphy had quite a bit of range among different rock styles.  The first two singles, "The Line Between the Devil's Teeth" and "Cuts You Up", were modern goth.  With any other successful album, releasing a slow love song like "A Strange Kind of Love" would have been totally acceptable as a third single.  Thing is, "The Line..." was virtually ignored upon its release, so the first song that most knew (even in the college radio and "120 Minutes" worlds) was "Cuts You Up".  Maybe people were on a high from that song and would rather listen to more dirge-y stuff, like that new thing from Seattle called grunge that was beginning to boil over rather than a percussionless, floating lullaby.  Some newer fans might have felt that the rug was being pulled out from under them, and some old Bauhaus fans who felt that they were re-connecting with him may have then thought "Cuts You Up" an anomaly.

Let's look at the other tracks on the album to see what might have been a more appropriate choice:

  • "Deep Ocean Vast Sea" - This one might have worked.  It was the leadoff track on the album, a slow thumper that picked up in intensity as it went along, with Murphy's vocals low on the register, which made them all the more powerful.
  • "Shy" - It's fun to listen to, don't get me wrong, but trying to listen to him rap can make one a bit giggly.
  • "Crystal Wrists" - This one might also have worked, but for different reasons.  It was almost acoustic-sounding, but not at all tentative, seemingly bridging a gap between an out-and-out love song and a singer-songwriter piece.  It might have even expanded his net a little bit further with that in mind.
  • "Marlene Dietrich's Favourite Poem" - Too slow and quiet.
  • "Seven Veils" - Another great track, but it was too long, clocking in at just under six minutes.  It kinda needed all six, so editing it might not have worked.
  • "The Line..." - Why not re-release it?  Well, the chorus was a little clunky.
  • "Roll Call" - First, it was too long, and second, it was really kinda aimless, and it would have been difficult to get onto radio.  It was better suited for the clubs.
Maybe Murphy's musical and creative arc went that way because that's what he wanted, so there would have been no point to trying to make him out to be something that he no longer wanted to be.  No one has a crystal ball.  I only have my opinion, and it's 25 years too late to be of use to anyone.  I was just wondering.

Sunday, March 8, 2015

"From Out of Nowhere" - Faith No More

I just saw the video for this song for the first time the other day on VH1's "120 Minutes".  (I used to love "120 Minutes" on MTV back in the 1990s, but that's a conversation for another day.)  It was a very distant-looking video, the band playing in concert, grainy, with little or no closeups on any of the band members, and sketchy and lazy synching of the vocals with the action on screen.

I started to think about why the label allowed them to do this.  I mean, this was Faith No More..."Epic", right?  Why have such a cold-looking video?  Wasn't Mike Patton a borderline heart-throb (well, not really, but maybe to some weird metal chicks)?

Then I remembered - this was the first single released from 1989's "The Real Thing".  It's the first album since they replaced original vocalist Chuck Moseley with Patton.  I don't think the label knew what to do with them.  They were a little too heavy to be an "alternative" band, but they had synthesizers and a whiny lead singer, so they really weren't "metal" either.  I think they were hoping not to get labeled as a Chili Peppers rip-off, though the similarities could have potentially gotten them attention.

They picked a great leadoff single, but the uninteresting video makes it clear that they weren't even trying to make a splash with the band, possibly thinking that "We Care a Lot" couldn't be topped, and that they were just an unfocused band and on the way out.  As a single, this went nowhere, but they managed to put a few ideas into play with "Epic", and a happier story (for everyone but guitarist Jim Martin) went from there.