Comebacks. Some work, but most don't. Sleater-Kinney, obviously awesome (I'll try to stop gushing over them). Gang of Four, good, but not great. Some of it is interesting, but it hardly seems vital. Helmet had a comeback that started out OK but ended up sounding downright depressing.
If you are getting back together for the money, that's one thing. You had a good following, a few albums that you can still sell, you weren't able to do anything else that fulfilling or lucrative, and your band still gets along, kinda. But can you still come up with the same magic?
OK maybe that doesn't matter. You're cashing in a little, serving those who don't expect more from you than to go through the motions as long as you get them off by playing decent enough versions of the hits. You can play Jones Beach every summer at the very least.
But then again, if you only developed a cult following as a college radio band, you won't fill stadiums, especially if your band hasn't come into a Slint-like "Oh, man, I wish I had seen them when they were around" status during your hiatus. That's when you do need that "magic" to come back. If it doesn't, you wind up sounding like a really weak version of your former self, and even your dedicated fans will just miss the old you and wish you had stayed retired.
It's a little extreme, I know, and it's sort of unfair to criticize a band who created and released to the public a new piece that is simply meant to be enjoyed. I just wish it was better.