Sunday, November 20, 2016

"Same to You" - Lydia Loveless

Back in August of this year, Lydia Loveless released her third album, Real (fourth if you count The Only Man, which she has all but disavowed).  That same month, she announced tour dates for the northeast US, where I reside, and after checking in with a buddy of mine who is a mutual fan, we agreed to get tickets to go to the Bowery Ballroom show in New York City.

I made sure to get the tickets the day they were released.  Actually, the hour they opened up the box office online.  Why, you ask?  After these three progressively "bigger"-sounding albums, I really felt like this was to be her big crossover/breakthrough.  To me, it wasn't any more apparent that she had truly "arrived" than with the album's opener, "Same to You".

The guitar, bass and drums all kick in with the first note, and the vocals don't wait but 14 seconds before starting up.  Her lover is furious with her.  If she talks back, he'll teach her a lesson, with pain.  This is not unusual for their relationship.  She could leave, but she's afraid she doesn't have enough resources to make it on her own.  Or maybe she just doesn't have the energy.  She's dependent on him, but, if you really don't care about me, the spell you have me under will be broken, and I'll go.

The vocal bridge comes in, and it's a doozy.  Is there anything that can take us back to how we felt when we started this journey?  When I fell for the way you used to look at me?  No?  OK, then just have the decency to let me go, and "wave goodbye".  Then I'll know it's over.

That's when the song turns from from sad to gut-wrenching.  When she belts "just wave goodbye", she holds the last note not just for aural effect, but also as if to hold onto that last syllable as if it was a chess piece after making a move.  You're not sure if you really want to finish the move because you're waiting for some sign from your opponent that you made the right move.  Maybe he still wants her.  Maybe she still wants this life.

Unfortunately for the listener, this struggle ends unresolved, but it has no less power with that known.  Live, the sound was just as lush and piercing as on the record.  

I just wish there were more people around to hear it.  I met my friend to see her at the Bowery Ballroom the other night, and there were less than 300 people there.  I felt really bad, like I should have bought more tickets to help out.  She's not Taylor Swift - she doesn't sing poppy songs, though they are getting more catchy.  Her lyrics though are more profane and contain more serious subject matter, though the heartbreak is universal.  I understand she'll never have the same mass appeal as T-Swift, but she really deserves better. 

I hope that this song isn't a metaphor for her music career.  I want to hear more from her, but she is young enough that she can go do something else and just stop all this if it's not getting her anywhere.  I'm not appealing to people to listen to her out of charity.  I'm just telling you that I love what she does, and she is a rare talent to get her messages across sounding as big as anyone else out there.  I wish her all the good luck in the world.

Sunday, November 6, 2016

"Rise Above" - Black Flag

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fsbvo5GVK10

Back again after another layoff (all the licensing testing I was doing for the past 2 years is over now!), and just in time for the scariest time of year - Election Day.


I was thinking the other day about what makes a good punk (or hardcore) rock song, so I investigated it how most others would these days - I looked it up on the internet.  The first website that came up was a wikiHow page on creating a good punk song.  Wow, was it ever useless.  I mean, I don't know much about writing music, but not only is it written for people who know nothing about punk, but it's also just, well, wrong.  It makes blanket statements like how the drums must always be fast, which is just ridiculous, because how would the drummer be able to keep up that pace for a live show?  (More on that in a future post.)


So I looked at a Quora post, and back in December of last year, author Mike Bowerbank seemed to sum it up fairly well:  


"Find your passion. Channel your outrage. Put it to music."  

https://www.quora.com/How-do-I-write-a-good-punk-song


I'm sure this not the only verse on the subject, but it's actually pretty good.  Missing any one of those three items, and you don't have a punk song.  (I'm equating the notion of a "punk" song and a "hardcore" song for the purposes of this post, even though I'm fully aware that they are significantly different.)


You have to be passionate about it.  If you're not, the conviction you are trying to portray will not come through or in the performance.  Most people can tell the difference.  You can try to mask that lacking by putting a catchy tune underneath it, and people may buy it for the sound, but something that is accessible is not necessarily good.  There are thousands of pop songs that are popular more for the way they sound than for whether the fans of the song believe and connect with the singer.  It's not necessarily useful from any artistic perspective; it's just accessible.  You need to have a clear message, it has to be about something, and you have to truly believe it, or you won't be able to convey it.


You have to have a message.  It must be about something that's important to you, and hopefully to others as well.  If it's too focused on your isolated problem, that no one else can relate to or would be offended by you even bringing it up (e.g. you get mad because the poor people on the street are asking you for money, not because the government is not doing enough to help them).  The government didn't do this, or the government didn't do that...someone is corrupt and took a bribe or caved to corporate interests that made lots of people's lives worse, that sort of thing.  That message must be clear in your music.  Not crystal clear, because a lot of punk bands get by with unintelligible lyrics, but if your message gets out, all the better.


Most music needs actual music.  Now, in the end, it's art, so the fans cannot dictate what you sound like.  You have to decide that for yourself.  It can be slow, or fast, or mid-level speed; it can change speeds; it can have no underlying music and be all vocals...it's up to the artist.  Spoken word technically isn't music, so if if there's no music sheet underlying some instrument, it's more difficult to sell.  But we're talking about punk songs here.  If it's more accessible, you have a better chance of it catching on.  But if you're a true artist, you make it sound however you please and hope that people at least respect it, even if they don't enjoy it.


Let's apply all this to "Rise Above", probably the best overall song from Black Flag, as well as being their most well-known.  Are they passionate?  Hell yes.  At the time it was written in the late 1970s-early 1980s, punk rock was under attack.  It wasn't just the idealists that were after them.  The police were actively seeking out punk shows to put a hurt on the artists as well as anyone else that got in their way.  There are plenty of stories of bands taking their licks from the police during this time, though since they are all one-sided stories, I will not get into any details.  I will only say that the bands often used their music to vent their frustrations.  And they were frustrated.  When the lyrics kick in, it's then-new vocalist Henry Rollins that leads the charge, and after just one phrase, the rest of the band roars, "Rise above! / We're gonna rise above!"  They're announcing that they're all here, standing together, and this matters, at least to them.


Do they have a message?  Oh yeah.  


People that can't do what we do so well put us down in an effort to control and/or stop us.  We have a chance to do something here, and we're taking it.  We're not letting you stop us, and we won't sink to your level.  We'll do it together, because we know the bond makes us stronger.  Want to stop us?  Go ahead - except, our fans know we're right, and you're wrong.  You don't know how to fight both us and our followers.


Does it have music?  Yep.  Kicking off with a surf-guitar riff akin to the Dead Kennedys style, it almost sounds like an emergency vehicle siren before quickly speeding up the tempo to a low-end anthemic riff, and then Rollins and the band let loose the vocals in a call-and-response pattern, with the aforementioned shouted two-line refrain.  That refrain is every bit a classic, and it is repeated throughout the song just like a protest chant.  Any fan of the song will just shout along, and if you're like me, it doesn't matter how old you are.  (It saves some embarrassment if you're by yourself, though, as cops beating up punks is not relatable these days.)


Does every punk song have to follow these guidelines?  Of course not.  Punk artists will not only talk about protest but personal relationships, as their lives can be just as complicated as anyone else's.  They love, they lose, and their home lives can be anywhere from normal to dysfunctional to horrifying.  They were always people too.  
But they found a way to get their emotions out and reach out to others creatively.  You can protest about whatever injustices you feel there are.  This is only one of your options.