I didn't like this song when I first heard it, but it has seriously grown on me since then. Way back when, my prudish mind couldn't appreciate the Pogues because I felt that Shane MacGowan's general drunken demeanor was not something to be lauded, and, my God, those TEETH. I didn't know anything about Kirsty MacColl, but I dismissed her as well simply by her association with them.
So I tried to ignore it. But it had legs. And why did it have legs? As the 1990s went on, there was a growing rejection of more synthetic music. Tastes changed to the more realistic, or if not completely realistic, at least pulled down from cloud nine. The lyrics and the energy in this song were ultimately undeniable.
The song starts with a piano and light string section as MacGowan sings lethargically about spending Christmas Eve night in a holding cell after being picked up (probably) for public drunkenness. He is not initially apologetic, but in seeing the others in the cell in a similar state, he beings to understand how fortunate he is to have someone at home who cares about him, and that he cares about, and he beings to lament.
The music picks up steam with a rhythm section and an accordion, and it's Ms. MacColl's turn. She marvels at how massive everything is in New York City compared to wherever she is from, but jeez it's really cold at Christmastime. All of that is bearable because Shane told her the first time they met that he was going to make a star of her in the Big Apple. With that hope, the gorgeous holiday singing of the police department choir, and the Christmas church bells ringing, she's a kid again, and she can just forget about everything else.
And then the song flips over. The fierce bickering, the brutal name-calling (FYI this is NOT a Christmas song for the kiddies), the very specific complaints - it seems like they both want to blame each other for their failings and current status in life. Finally, both realize what they really want to blame each other for is their co-dependency.
The question is whether they both want to keep their relationship going. I think that's up to the listener, as you only hear from MacGowan from that point, and I think the tenderness, however jaded, in his singing is his way of telling her that he still chooses her.
But, maybe he's just still good at conning her.
Happy Holidays, Everyone.
Sunday, December 20, 2015
Sunday, December 6, 2015
"I Am the Virus" - Killing Joke
I was reading Mark Deming's review on Allmusic.com of Killing Joke's latest album, "Pylon", and he mentioned how great it was to hear them "this furious and effective" after such a long career. It got me thinking.
Who has a 35-year career like this? Plenty of bands have serious longevity - the Stones, obviously, but the Stones serve a very different purpose. Their rebellion, if you can call it that, was arguably centered around an alternative to the clean-cut Beatles. Their ability to write and play blues-rock very seriously, while not taking themselves that seriously, allowed for a rare combination that has hung around since before I was born.
The Stones have been effective, but not furious. Furious burns out. Punk bands are generally younger folk, and they appeal to younger folk. Now, younger folk will always be around, but I know for me, my tastes changed as I got older. I haven't stopped listening to punk, but I found myself wanting more. Many artists change their styles too. Elvis Costello and Joe Jackson started out as "angry young men", but it didn't take that long for their music to be drastically more mature than their very early releases.
So who else is still furious? There is, of course, plenty to be angry about these days. Terrorism, the world economy, mass murders, gun control, and, well, HATE. Chances are that if you have at least 100 friends on social media, you are going to see at least one post per day about ISIS, Muslims, Donald Trump talking about Muslims, or people telling those other people to shut up. I'm not here claiming to know the solution to this. No one does. However, that doesn't stop many people from spewing their own, to put it mildly, pointed rhetoric.
Killing Joke has been that rare band that can repeatedly create compelling music that is incredibly angry yet not blinded by its own fury. They have not done so at every turn. They have had their ups and downs over 35 years. They have had lineup changes, and they have suffered from ego problems just like any other band. The bottom was probably their 1988 album "Outside the Gate", which was not really furious and pretty ineffective. They broke up after that album, but since their reformation with the original lineup in 2003, they have been piercing Western politics while still understanding that their message is best delivered through fierce, bile-filled projectile vomit.
That is not to say the quality of the music is akin to vomit. It's angry but focused, and some of it is even catchy. The more accessible tunes convey some hope. They have been around long enough to know that you can only get so far bellowing at your followers without offering plausible ideas on solutions, or at the very least, hope. And you have to be convincing. You have to believe what you're saying, and it has to come out in the recordings, or you will be found out and ignored.
The band continues to protest, they do their homework, and they don't take their fans for granted. At the same time, they point their weapons at those in charge. You don't have to believe in my ideals, but you better show me you're making an honest effort to try to fix things, or I'm going to continue to skewer you and get my message out to anyone that will listen.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)