Sunday, December 20, 2015

"Fairytale of New York" - The Pogues with Kirsty MacColl (Part 2)

I didn't like this song when I first heard it, but it has seriously grown on me since then.  Way back when, my prudish mind couldn't appreciate the Pogues because I felt that Shane MacGowan's general drunken demeanor was not something to be lauded, and, my God, those TEETH.  I didn't know anything about Kirsty MacColl, but I dismissed her as well simply by her association with them.

So I tried to ignore it.  But it had legs.  And why did it have legs?  As the 1990s went on, there was a growing rejection of more synthetic music.  Tastes changed to the more realistic, or if not completely realistic, at least pulled down from cloud nine.  The lyrics and the energy in this song were ultimately undeniable.  

The song starts with a piano and light string section as MacGowan sings lethargically about spending Christmas Eve night in a holding cell after being picked up (probably) for public drunkenness.  He is not initially apologetic, but in seeing the others in the cell in a similar state, he beings to understand how fortunate he is to have someone at home who cares about him, and that he cares about, and he beings to lament.

The music picks up steam with a rhythm section and an accordion, and it's Ms. MacColl's turn.  She marvels at how massive everything is in New York City compared to wherever she is from, but jeez it's really cold at Christmastime.  All of that is bearable because Shane told her the first time they met that he was going to make a star of her in the Big Apple.  With that hope, the gorgeous holiday singing of the police department choir, and the Christmas church bells ringing, she's a kid again, and she can just forget about everything else.

And then the song flips over.  The fierce bickering, the brutal name-calling (FYI this is NOT a Christmas song for the kiddies), the very specific complaints - it seems like they both want to blame each other for their failings and current status in life.  Finally, both realize what they really want to blame each other for is their co-dependency.

The question is whether they both want to keep their relationship going.  I think that's up to the listener, as you only hear from MacGowan from that point, and I think the tenderness, however jaded, in his singing is his way of telling her that he still chooses her.  

But, maybe he's just still good at conning her.

Happy Holidays, Everyone.  

No comments:

Post a Comment