Monday, December 7, 2020

The Great Re-Rip of 2020, Day 111, December 4, 2020

Artist:  10,000 Maniacs

Title:  The Wishing Chair

Where bought:  Tower Records

I bought 10,000 Maniacs' "The Wishing Chair" after I was turned onto them by "In My Tribe".  I put it on the cassette player when my high school friends piled into a car to do college visits one day.  They didn't like it.  I was more patient with it, as I had already listened to it several times, but they were turned off by the higher-pitched Natalie Merchant.  I understood.  They had not found their correct sound by that point, but to their credit, they did try a whole bunch of different sounds on this one, with some inspired by their even earlier indie work (my friends hated "Hope Chest" even more than this one) - "Pit Viper" may have been an inspiration for "The Colonial Wing", probably the most unique song in the band's catalog.  

Some of these songs even signaled work on "In My Tribe".  "Daktari", a bonus cut, bears a resemblance to "My Sister Rose".  One complaint about the sequencing, though.  On the cassette, the album seemed to flow better, ending with "My Mother the War", a majestic track, but the CD ends with "Arbor Day", a jaunty, bouncy, traditional-sounding song that ends the album on a hard cut.  Didn't seem right to me.


Artist:  10,000 Maniacs

Title:  Blind Man's Zoo

Where bought:  The Wiz

After the classic that is "In My Tribe", I could not wait to listen to the follow-up from 10,000 Maniacs, "Blind Man's Zoo".  The anticipation was heightened after hearing the pre-release single, "Trouble Me", a light but still enjoyable pop song.  

The reception to this one was not as strong as its predecessor.  Where "In My Tribe" was more "macro", dealing with big problems with a knowledgeable yet gentle touch, "Blind Man's Zoo" was more "micro", blowing up specific problems in a heavy-handed fashion, and I think it turned some people off.  "Please Forgive Us" chastises politicians over the Iran-Contra affair.  "The Lion's Share" likens commerce to the jungle, where the biggest companies seemingly cannot be stopped.  "Jubilee" ends the album on a particularly ugly note in a discussion about impenetrable racism in the US.  

Now, alongside these are some other songs that could have been on the previous release.  "You Happy Puppet" is a cleaner-sounding, slightly accusatory song about trying to get out of a routine-based life.  "Eat for Two" is a first-person examination of an unwanted pregnancy.  Understandably, the band took a few years to re-tool before releasing the fantastic "Our Time in Eden".


Artist:  10,000 Maniacs

Title:  Our Time in Eden

Where bought:  The Wiz

The last 10,000 Maniacs studio album with Natalie Merchant, "Our Time in Eden", is just about the equivalent of "In My Tribe".  They went for a bigger sound, complete with additional but not overbearing instrumentation ("Noah's Dove", "Few and Far Between"), and it paid off tremendously.  

The subject matter of the lyrics, not shying away from tougher topics ("Jezebel", an even-handed look at a crumbling marriage, and "Gold Rush Brides", about such women's struggles in that period), are presented more naturally and not as heavy-handed as the last album.  In fact, a bunch of the songs on the first half of the album seem downright happy ("These Are Days", "Eden").  Throughout it all, Merchant sounds as relaxed as ever, her range of emotions on display effortlessly, and I mean that in the most complimentary way.  A glorious end to this chapter in their careers. 


Artist:  10,000 Maniacs

Title:  MTV Unplugged

Where bought:  The Wiz

I know what you're thinking.  "Where's 'In My Tribe'?"  You're correct to wonder about that.  For the longest time, the only copy I had of that one was missing "Peace Train", because the band was upset with Cat Stevens and had later pressings remove the song.  I recently found a CD with the song in it, so I sold my old copy and re-ripped the new one at the right quality, so it's not technically part of this big re-rip.  That said, I'm glad they included some songs from that album on their "MTV Unplugged" session, because it was by far the best studio release from the band, and since I could go on forever geeking out about it, I'll stop the whole thing here, because 339 blog posts in less than for months is a lot, and I'm tired

No comments:

Post a Comment