Saturday, July 21, 2012

"Kiss Them for Me" - Diane Birch/The Phenomenal Handclap Band

First things first.  Yes, this is a cover of Siouxsie and the Banshees' breakthrough/crossover/cringe-inducing hit.  Second, I only like covers when the sound is drastically changed into something that sounds like the band covering it would have made on their own (see:  Quicksand's "How Soon Is Now?" and the Cowboy Junkies' "Sweet Jane").

I don't mention songs to be pretentious, but to try to make a point as clearly as I can.  If you are not going to change the song, there is no point in covering it, unless you are a bar band.  Bar bands can get away with this because people generally don't go to bars to hear "new stuff".  They want to hear their favorites close to the original format because they don't want to think while they drink.

Serious recording artists should know better, and many of them do.  Should Faith No More have covered the Commodores' "Easy"?  It's a joke to make it sound like the original even though it's white guys covering a black band, ok, I got that.  But it still sounded too much like the original to stand on its own.  And Primus' "Making Plans for Nigel"?  Primus has such a distinct low-end, melody-less sound, it's kind of a disappointment to hear them come so close to making a pop song.

I could go on for hours about this, but this song snagged my interest ever since I first heard it being pumped through the speaker system at a shopping mall about two hours ago.  Now, I hate the original, and it's not just because I'm a purist.  Not only is the song lighter than air and the video nauseatingly pretty for a classic goth band, but they used the same percussion riff that about ten other songs were using at the time (e.g. Chapterhouse, John Mellencamp).  But this version actually does a good job.  Now, the lyrics were never great to begin with, but turning this crystalline, trippy dance tune into a country-soul twanger worked.  Had I never heard the original, I would have thought this version was the original.  Any idea how rare that is?  I'll probably never hear this woman and this band again played anywhere, but, now I can say I've heard of them.

No comments:

Post a Comment